Dear I., congratulations on your great mothering instincts. Unfortunately it is not uncommon for fathers and mothers to have different thoughts on parenting. This will continue as you co-parent your daughter. Our cultural mores that are not related to what a wealth of research has told us about what is normal for babies as biological creatures make parenting much more difficult. Sleeping with babies is the biological norm. Research shows that when safe co-sleeping is practiced, the risk of SIDS is reduced greatly. No other species expects its vulnerable young to sleep alone for hours at a time. Please check for the research of Dr Sears and james mcKenna to read about the benefits of co-sleeping.
Have you had a conversation with your husband about why he wants the baby to sleep elsewhere? is he getting pressure from family members; is he afraid the baby will become too dependent (for heavens sake, of course she is dependent, she is an infant!); does he want more cuddle time with you etc.? Talk to him with "I" statements, telling him how you feel and why you think this is best. Trust your instincts! So many of our modern parenting guidelines promoted by "experts" teach mothers they must ignore their instincts. But if you can't trust your gut, what can you trust? Gosh, women used to be considered the experts in the matters related to childcare, not professionals who are mostly men! When and why did we abdicate this role to others?
Please do not let your baby cry it out! her crying is her way of telling you that something is wrong. If she is not responded to, she will be unable to fully trust, which is the basis of emotional health and the ability to form healthy relationships with other humans. Again there is a wealth of research in this area that contradicts this method. prolonged crying floods the baby's brain with stress hormones. the brain is then programmed to respond with high levels of stress hormones to relatively minor future stresses. These hormones affect crucial areas of the baby's forming brain that affect emotion and impulse control. An infant's brain is a work in progress and undergoes a tremendous amount of growth in the first year; at one year it will be 70% of its adult size! How we care for our infants determines how their brains develop for a lifetime, for good or ill.
I urge you to contact your local La leche league. They have lots of books you can check out for free that will help you learn more about what babies really need. A good book that I love is called "Our babies, Ourselves". There is an excellent book you can get from LLL that is now out of print claled "Mothering and fathering: The gender differences in parenting."
I am very disturbed by all of the references to Baby Wise. This is the only parenting method that has been condemned by the American Academy of Pediatrics, and can be dangerous for babies both emotionally and physically. Great online sources for information about breastfeeding and responsive parenting are kellymom.com and flca.info. (FLCA stands for Florida lactation Consultant Association).There is a good link from the FLCA site that explores Baby Wise in detail.
I have posted a number of times on topics related to this; if you wish you can go to the files and read other posts I have written. I have been a parenting educator for 25 years and I am a board certified lactation consultant. As a new mom it is very difficult to know what is the right thing to do. Others can tell you what worked or didn;t work for them, but you know your baby and yourself better than anyone else. If she tells you she needs you, listen to her and trust her. She will develop and become more independent at her own pace. This is so important; please take the time to learn what the research shows concerning what human babies truly need from their caregivers. Go to the link below and read this great article to start your own research:
http://www.naturalchild.org/jan_hunt/baby_borrowers.html
Good luck to you!
J.