A real one. Hands down. It doesn't have to be expensive ($50 or less, same price as Legos!)... But TRUST me on not getting a toy.
I'm a huge proponent of real cameras for kids. Here's why.
- Decent pictures. Which is really key. 6MP will take decent photos. Kids often take amaaaaazing shots (in a slew of bad ones), just because their perspective is different. But it has to be capable of taking good pictures to begin with. But BEYOND that, kids won't keep using something that takes bad pictures.
- Use!!! As in a good camera will get used for YEARS. The Nikon CoolPix I got my son on a cyber monday deal when he was 3 or 4 is still in use (almost daily), and he's 10!!! It was a $200 camera I got for $50. Even if it were full price, that's a steal. At $50? That less than $10 a year!
- Easy Button. Real cameras are made to be easy. You can download pictures easily, and well, with no wacky software to buy or weird cords/docks/etc that simply aren't made well. Ditto, real cameras are about 100 times easier to use than the clunky toy versions.
- Durability. "Kids" / toy cameras LOOK sturdy. They're not. They're cheaply made, which crappy parts. They break VERY easily (and when they break, you're up a creek). Real cameras have built in shock protection (and stabilizing, etc.). So they're actually a lot tougher. They're DESIGNED to be shoved in pockets, dropped on the floor, driven around in shaky cars, sat on, etc. And if a real camera breaks? You mail it in and it gets refurbished and mailed back to you (or a new one). Most of the tech holiday sales are over... But if you pick up a camera at a pawnshop (or Craigslist, or a hand-me-down)... So you don't have a warranty... They're STILL able to be fixed by the company (or repair place).
- Cost. Again. Not only cheaper in the long run even if you buy full price (I wouldn't)... But DO check with friends to see if anyone has an old 6MP (or 7,8,etc.) that they've upgraded. Hand me downs are free (or $20, etc.).
.... And ON the thought of handmedowns... If she's currently using your phone camera... You can get a handmedown PHONE. It doesn't have to have service to get plugged in and used as a camera :)
Something I've personally noticed, is that kids don't CARE if it's "new". They care about GETTING it. In fact, they'd rather not have to deal with packaging. As long as its wrapped, and works, they're ecstatic.