L.W.
Hi A.,
Don't over think this situation, keep it simple is my philosophy for buying gifts for kids that I know and don't know. My daughter happens to love paper dolls, so every girl's birthday party she attends gets my daughter's favorite book of paper dolls. I have a $20 limit, but you can find a wealth of things in $5 or $10 range, like coloring books, the crayola art packs or a book. My daughter is always very appreciative of the gifts she receives from friends, because they are usually things that I would not ordinarily buy her.