L.B.
Ok, here's my guess at whats going on - Sounds like your describing Dyscalculia (Math Dyslexia). If I were to further guess, your daughter is very bright little girl - it is because of this that she has found ways to work around to get to the answers up until now. I suggest googling dyslexia & dyscalculia and read the descriptions. If it all rings true to you give Michigan Dyslexia Institute in Berkley a call. If this is what is going on with her, there is hope. She can be taught "tricks" for getting the job done. Btw, public schools generally don't consider evaluating for these things until the third grade. They will tell you accurate testing can not be done until 3rd grade. Funny thing though, the professionals that conduct the testing , teachers & tutors for this will tell you they have worked with kids as young as 4 years. Good Luck!