Photo by:  J Franklin

Stay-at-Home Mommy Myths

by Katrina J. Cummins, MEd
Photo by: J Franklin

It was 5:00pm, which we like to call “happy hour” in our household, and my husband walked in the front door after a long day at work. As he walked through the toy obstacle course, saw the mountain of laundry on the couch, and dirty dishes in the sink he smiled and asked that one question that pushed my mommy button, “What did you do all day?” Smiling, I replied “It must be nice to have a lunch break and get a paycheck for your hard work”. At that time we had a five and a three year old home and I was a stay-at-home-mom.

I had been previously working as a professional and choose to cut and paste my schedule from working full time, down to part time, then to SAHM. I learned to navigate this landscape where there was no set job description, no 9 – 5 schedule, no evaluation, no thirty minute lunch break and no paycheck deposited into our bank account.

Two Camps
Reading and talking to lots of different moms, whether at the park, work or classroom, there seems to be two main camps that mommies hang out in. Either “Stay-at-Home Mommy” camp or “Work-Outside-the-House Mommy” camp.

There seems to be some tension between these two camps with an “us” verses “them” mentality. But as moms we need to be on the same team, camping out together, supporting and encouraging each other because mothering is tough on a good day.

I have camped out in both areas and have found that both have rewards and challenges. Everyone seems to have an opinion about whether a woman should be at home raising children or working outside the home. There seems to be a value judgment placed on those moms who stay at home raising their children.

Myths
Why is it that sometimes when we meet women and find out that they stay at home raising their children, we instantly assume things about them without really knowing them? I remember meeting a mom at a social function and chatting about our lives. I asked her a few questions and she said that she was a teacher. I asked her what school she worked at and found out she hadn’t worked as a teacher in over five years. I’ll never forget how this woman expressed her feeling that she would be accepted and valued more if she worked in a paid job. I have consistently run into different ideas about SAHMs. Some of these thoughts are myths which need to be addressed and openly discussed.

Some common myths about SAHMs suggest that they are:

  • uneducated
  • throwing away their education
  • not really working as they are not in a real paid job
  • lucky to be wealthy to stay home
  • have the luxury of all this free time
  • not using their brains
  • unproductive
  • not using their gifts or talents
  • not able to handle the many pressures that working mom’s encounter.

Integrating Life
Every woman is different and each family has their own unique needs to be addressed. Being a SAHM is tough work and even though they may not pack up their brief case and walk out the front door to go to a paid job, nevertheless it is still work 24/7. From the physical work of cleaning to emotional work of handling the many different emotions of a toddler.

One of the biggest myths is that SAHM are wealthy and have the luxury to stay home. This myth needs to be kicked out of our neighborhoods and challenged. So many SAHM are struggling financially and make personal sacrifices to stay at home. They are skilled at finding a bargain and inexpensive activities, showing a kind of money savvy that should be welcomed in any business board room. SAHMs have to be money savvy working out how they can manage a tight budget so they can continue to be at home.

They use their education in different ways, such as working in their child’s classroom or volunteering in the community. Nowadays many more moms are running their own business from home with a creative schedule. They handle complex schedules from play dates, naps, carpooling to classroom volunteering. Their mommy brain and cell phone is always “on”, giving new meaning to multi-tasking with an ability to handle the many pressures placed on them.

Interestingly enough, research is finding that many woman are leaving their high paying jobs and careers to be at home with their kids (CBS News, 2004). With the many demands placed on them, SAHMs have very little free time and are highly productive in raising children, the future of our society.

Life is a Journey
Working as a counselor I have found a common thread woven between all of us; none of us are perfect or have perfect kids. We all have struggles along this journey called ‘life’. Maybe your journey is to be a SAHM mom right now. When the journey gets bumpy I encourage you to take time out for yourself. Maybe have coffee with a girlfriend or treat your self to a pedicure. When you are living on your last nerve, remind yourself that your kids are at home for such a short amount of time, pretty soon they will be packing up and walking out your front door to explore their own adventure.

At the end of the day other people’s opinions and judgments really don’t matter. What matters is that what you are doing, you are doing to the best of your ability with a right attitude, finding fulfillment along the way using your gifts and abilities.

Suggested Reading:
Stay at Home Survival Guide (2008)
Melissa Stanton The Mommy Brain (2005), Katherine Ellison

Katrina J. Cummins MEd lives near Portland, Oregon and balances her time between speaking, counseling and working full time as a wife and mother.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

132 Comments

Thank you SO MUCH for this article...I cannot tell you how many times I have heard how lucky I am to be able to stay at home.....like being a SAHM is codde word for relaxing all day and hanging out at the spa:) Yes, being with my kids is a huge blessing, but it is not always easy and there are many times when I would not describe my situation as "lucky"! It is hard work and there are no scheduled breaks or clock out times....you are there 24/7 no matter what...

See entire comment

I LOVED the first comment about the joke re: "what did you do all day?" There isn't a SAHM that hasn't heard that one before! (or a SAHD!) If you think you can do a better job....well, then you give it your best shot! ;) My hubby can't handle a whole day, let alone a weekend or whole WEEK! LOL!
And why is it that they think they can do better than us? My hubby has said numerous times "we can trade places if you'd like." Well, no thanks...I don't want to deal with idiots anymore, I perfer my own children, but that doesn't mean I don't need a break now and again....it has nothing to do with "disliking" our job as SAHM, it has to do with HUMANE NATURE and our SANITY! I told hubby, "if you had to be with me 24/7, you'd need a break from me, too!" Am I right?

I just have to add....I have a Masters degree, was an executive before we had kids, and made as much $###,### as hubby. Before kids, we had plenty of money to do with whatever we wanted and still chose a house that was within limits of a single income, only had one car payment at a time and still have nice cars and "toys" (all paid for now!), no credit card debt, and have been very responsible financially...

See entire comment

I stayed at home with my son the first 2 yrs, but returned to work fulltime because we needed the money. I wish I could be a SAHM but don't have that choice. I get upset when I get 'the look' from SAHM at school as if I put my family second to work which is far from the truth. I and many moms at the office sacrifice our lunch hr to run errands, book dr's appts, and other mommy duties and we are constantly thinking about what to make for dinner as 5-6pm approaches...

See entire comment

I read this this morning and tears rolled down my face. I have been a SAHM for 6 years now with 3 kids. Although I wouldn't change it, I will admit this is the hardest job in the world. I don't believe anyone could understand that or appreciate it until they've lived it day in and day out. I have, at times, felt so isolated and very alone in motherhood. I've heard all of the disrespectful comments and seen all of the dirty looks...and there's always those who can't hold a door open for you...

See entire comment

Lorian...in response to your joke, what if you did do all of those things that you normally do all day and when you day was over, your house still looks like that? ;) anybody else in that boat?

thank you so much. i'm a sahm, and while i don't feel many judgments from working moms or society in general, i REALLY appreciate your recognition of the hard job of a mother, working or not. i wouldn't change my job for anything!

I'm a stay at home mom with a child in school and I had a nanny prior to my child starting school. It's unfortunate that "Amy" doesn't respect me as a mom but then maybe it's sour grapes rather than any real understanding of what it is to stand in someone else's shoes. I do not just moms who stay at home or those who work outside of the home. There are many reasons we make the choices we do whether it be financial, our own personal ethics or for sanity...

See entire comment

I am a working mom. I work 40 + hours a week. I am a volunteer at the school and have two children that play soccer. I take them to their practices and make their games. I have a problem with SAHM that are NOT involved with their children school or sport teams. What do you do all day/night? I feel that it is fine to stay home while you have non school-age children, but once they are in school, I think you should want to help your husband and work as a team to provide for your family...

See entire comment

i am a stay at home mom and have never worked out of the home after my kids were born. my husband has lost his job a few times and it is hard,but because i stay home i do the finances and save as much as possible, so that when things do get hard we have money to fall back on...

See entire comment

This is a great article. When my oldest son was 10 months old we were really struglling financially. I decided to go back to work. One night I was talking to my Sister in law who had 2 boys and was a stay at home Mom. They also struggled with finances but her decision was to stay home. Mine was different and I will never forget how I felt after hanging up that phone. She told me she couldn't understand how I could do it...

See entire comment

I have found that neither world all stay at home or all working works for me. I have been a stay at home mom, but to continuet that we never could have had 3 more as we would not have been able to feed them and I dealt with more depression then from teh isolation.

I also with 2 small children worked outside the home away from them for a year. This did not work either, it nearly killed me and did make me have a nervous breakdown...

See entire comment

Wow - Amy -
I'm sorry that volunteering hours at school and church, taking care of elderly parents, and accompanying extended family members to health care appointments doesn't deserve your respect.

Yes!
Read more my blog "Parenting is not a second-class vocation!" in www.daliacoachesparents.com
Instead of looking at the issues in terms of "camps", why don't we look at the option and see which is the right thing for each individual?

Dalia Orr

I was fortunate to be able to take extended maternity leaves (6 months and 9 months) and I was amazed and appalled at the "us vs. them" mentality between SAHM and working moms. I was reviled, chastised, and ignored at mommy group because I was returning to my teaching with the new school year. On the other hand, I had a hard time relating to a bunch of women who weren't interested in talking about anything but babies...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive

Related Questions

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all