Photo by:  J Franklin

Stay-at-Home Mommy Myths

by Katrina J. Cummins, MEd
Photo by: J Franklin

It was 5:00pm, which we like to call “happy hour” in our household, and my husband walked in the front door after a long day at work. As he walked through the toy obstacle course, saw the mountain of laundry on the couch, and dirty dishes in the sink he smiled and asked that one question that pushed my mommy button, “What did you do all day?” Smiling, I replied “It must be nice to have a lunch break and get a paycheck for your hard work”. At that time we had a five and a three year old home and I was a stay-at-home-mom.

I had been previously working as a professional and choose to cut and paste my schedule from working full time, down to part time, then to SAHM. I learned to navigate this landscape where there was no set job description, no 9 – 5 schedule, no evaluation, no thirty minute lunch break and no paycheck deposited into our bank account.

Two Camps
Reading and talking to lots of different moms, whether at the park, work or classroom, there seems to be two main camps that mommies hang out in. Either “Stay-at-Home Mommy” camp or “Work-Outside-the-House Mommy” camp.

There seems to be some tension between these two camps with an “us” verses “them” mentality. But as moms we need to be on the same team, camping out together, supporting and encouraging each other because mothering is tough on a good day.

I have camped out in both areas and have found that both have rewards and challenges. Everyone seems to have an opinion about whether a woman should be at home raising children or working outside the home. There seems to be a value judgment placed on those moms who stay at home raising their children.

Myths
Why is it that sometimes when we meet women and find out that they stay at home raising their children, we instantly assume things about them without really knowing them? I remember meeting a mom at a social function and chatting about our lives. I asked her a few questions and she said that she was a teacher. I asked her what school she worked at and found out she hadn’t worked as a teacher in over five years. I’ll never forget how this woman expressed her feeling that she would be accepted and valued more if she worked in a paid job. I have consistently run into different ideas about SAHMs. Some of these thoughts are myths which need to be addressed and openly discussed.

Some common myths about SAHMs suggest that they are:

  • uneducated
  • throwing away their education
  • not really working as they are not in a real paid job
  • lucky to be wealthy to stay home
  • have the luxury of all this free time
  • not using their brains
  • unproductive
  • not using their gifts or talents
  • not able to handle the many pressures that working mom’s encounter.

Integrating Life
Every woman is different and each family has their own unique needs to be addressed. Being a SAHM is tough work and even though they may not pack up their brief case and walk out the front door to go to a paid job, nevertheless it is still work 24/7. From the physical work of cleaning to emotional work of handling the many different emotions of a toddler.

One of the biggest myths is that SAHM are wealthy and have the luxury to stay home. This myth needs to be kicked out of our neighborhoods and challenged. So many SAHM are struggling financially and make personal sacrifices to stay at home. They are skilled at finding a bargain and inexpensive activities, showing a kind of money savvy that should be welcomed in any business board room. SAHMs have to be money savvy working out how they can manage a tight budget so they can continue to be at home.

They use their education in different ways, such as working in their child’s classroom or volunteering in the community. Nowadays many more moms are running their own business from home with a creative schedule. They handle complex schedules from play dates, naps, carpooling to classroom volunteering. Their mommy brain and cell phone is always “on”, giving new meaning to multi-tasking with an ability to handle the many pressures placed on them.

Interestingly enough, research is finding that many woman are leaving their high paying jobs and careers to be at home with their kids (CBS News, 2004). With the many demands placed on them, SAHMs have very little free time and are highly productive in raising children, the future of our society.

Life is a Journey
Working as a counselor I have found a common thread woven between all of us; none of us are perfect or have perfect kids. We all have struggles along this journey called ‘life’. Maybe your journey is to be a SAHM mom right now. When the journey gets bumpy I encourage you to take time out for yourself. Maybe have coffee with a girlfriend or treat your self to a pedicure. When you are living on your last nerve, remind yourself that your kids are at home for such a short amount of time, pretty soon they will be packing up and walking out your front door to explore their own adventure.

At the end of the day other people’s opinions and judgments really don’t matter. What matters is that what you are doing, you are doing to the best of your ability with a right attitude, finding fulfillment along the way using your gifts and abilities.

Suggested Reading:
Stay at Home Survival Guide (2008)
Melissa Stanton The Mommy Brain (2005), Katherine Ellison

Katrina J. Cummins MEd lives near Portland, Oregon and balances her time between speaking, counseling and working full time as a wife and mother.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

132 Comments

I think that one small way to help bridge the gap and help our society give equal respect to mothers who stay home with their children and those who have a paid outside job (and all those who fall into the nebulous area in between) is to STOP calling ourselves "mommies". I think the se of this child's term infantilizes women. I really dislike the term "stay-at-home-mommy" for this reason...

See entire comment

I am a SAHM of 4. Before deciding to stay home with my kids, I had been working on my career/experience for nearly 9 years. I have to say that for me being a SAHM is tough work but also the most rewarding. I believe my final decision came when I was trying to get pregnant with my 4th (and last). My two oldest children had field day at school and I had requested a half day off of work to go and be with them. Assured it wouldn't be a problem I was excited to go in that morning and put in my time...

See entire comment

I agree that mom's in both camps need to support each other. One thing I notice in many of the SAHM posts is the justification for their decisions that imply they have made the only 'right' decision. "I'm close with my kids", "My kids are well rounded", "I've molded a human mind". All of these statements in context imply the reverse is true for working moms. Working moms feel enough conflict and guilt without these judgements...

See entire comment

I work part time from home and spend the vast majority of my time running after my two kiddos. I have huge ambivalence about giving up the career track and having my part time job always take the back seat. I really do feel like no one takes me seriously now that I am not a full time employee somewhere. Yet, having worked in daycare during my college year I didn't want that for my little kids...

See entire comment

I am totally with Dalia's post on Nov 4. I also chose to work for the interests of the family. My husband has a very stable and good job, he is in good health and our marriage is strong, but what if?

I think this is great. I also started out working, went to part time and am now at home full time, not so much by choice, but enjoy it. In this economy, I think it's important to realize that sometimes, as much as the money is needed, it's not always an option. I have been out of the workforce for too long, and have moved to a very competitive market. I cannot get a job that pays for daycare, let alone leaves money after that...

See entire comment

Amen to the post! But I must agree with Dalia! I too was a professional working outside of the home and didn't realize how much time went by until my oldest child was starting Kindergarten!! I stopped working when my 2nd child turned 2 years old. However, I continued to try do what I can to contribute financially to our family. Like Dalia says we never know if our spouse may no longer be able to work...

See entire comment

I've lived in both "camps" and respect all Mommies. My oldest is nine now and I had to work. I also don't think that I would have enjoyed staying home with him at that point. I, as a poster above, enjoyed work and the break that it gave me. There were times on weekends and such that I just didn't know what things to do with him to keep him happy and flourishing. I was also pretty young. :)
My second son is two and after a three month maternity leave, I went back to work...

See entire comment

I have also been on both sides of the fence...working full time as an attorney, staying home full time and working part time. Every job has its perks; every job has its benefits. All moms should support every other mom's decision concerning working and raising kids. It irks me when I hear women say "no one can take care of a child as well as Mom." Bull. Having a uterus doesn't make you a good SAH Mom...

See entire comment

I think working mommies get judged just as much, if not more than SAHM. I mean, look at the comments. SAHMs commenting on how healthy and well-rounded their kids are *because* they stayed at home (implying the kids would not be as well-adjusted if they worked outside the home). And, the talk of molding young brains and creating close relationships with parents -- it's a bit smug to imply that this is the realm of SAHMs. I can do this just as well as a working mommy...

See entire comment

How many men get asked why they go back to work?

My husband is a stay at home dad of twins. He is so great (he sews, cooks and has remodelled our house during this time.) He really struggles with how he feels society views him as lazy, unemployable despite this being the hardest job he has ever had. On another note I always feel like the odd one out when I take time off and take the kids out on their daily routine, to preschool, park etc., with the other stay at home moms.

First, I'd like to respond by saying, not everyone has the OPTION to stay at home. I think all of the posts that I've read are from SAHM who are consistently discussing how their OPTION to stay home brought about well rounded children. I was raised by TWO working parents. My mother did not stay at home and I turned out to be quite well-rounded and successful. I think that people should not spend so much time trying to play up the decision that they made and simply live their lives...

See entire comment

I decided to be a stay-at-home mom because I absolutely adored my baby. I did it because my husband and I thought it would be best for our son. Who knew how much I would learn?! I have become a future thinker to avoid the grumpies that come with poor naptime planning or poor mealtime planning. I've learned to prioritize with the 30 minutes I get to myself each day. I'm learning how to cook healthy yet cheap meals. I'm learning to resist impulse purchases. I'm learning how to manage stress...

See entire comment

I think this dialogue is so important and is the product of the freedom TO choose. We should support each other because in the end, we are all just doing the best we can with what we have and I agree that, for me, staying home all day, day after day, would be so hard to manage. I NEED to go out into the world and contribute to society. It is something that fulfills me deeply, separate from my children. And the idea of giving that up full-time, makes me feel like one fourth of myself...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive

Related Questions

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all