Back story: I have b/g twins. DS pretty much STTN, but DD still wakes a few times. She has little trouble going to sleep at bedtime, or going down for naps. She can go down with a bottle, without a bottle, completely awake, asleep...the putting to bed part is relatively easy. She can self-soothe back to sleep during naps, too.
Up until now, when she wakes during the night, I nurse her and she goes back to sleep very easily. Last night, I decided it was time to get her to try to self-soothe. Babies went to bed at 8. DD woke up just before 1am. I didn't get her right away, let her grumble it out for a while. She wasn't exactly crying, but she was grumbling a lot. It would get quiet as if she was going back to sleep and then she'd start moving around and making noise again. After 20 minutes, she started to really cry. I gave her a paci, which she took vigorously, and a stuffed animal that stays in her crib. She lied WIDE AWAKE sucking paci, or playing with it for 10 minutes and then rolled over and went to sleep. YAY...but wait...5 minutes later she woke up again. I tried to just leave her, but after another 10 minutes, she was really upset. I finally gave in, got her, nursed her, and we both went back to sleep until 4am, when her brother woke up hungry.
My plan is to make her wait a little longer each night until eventually, she's only nursing in the morning. Like tonight, I'll make her wait until 2:30. I'm not sure it'll work, and if she's laying there wide awake, I don't see how that's helping. Plus, what if she's really hungry and I'm forcing her back to sleep uncomfortably? She is a healthy weight baby, but is rather picky about the amount she'll eat. I can't increase her servings during the day; she'll only eat what she wants - 1oz, 3 oz, 6...whatever she's in the mood for.
I'm just not sure of what method or strategy to use to see if she'll sleep more at night. She doesn't wake up for the morning until 6:30 or 7. And even then, I can sleep a little more, until her brother wakes up too, and she'll play quietly in her crib until 7:30.
My gut tells me she'll grow out of it and that I should just keep getting her when she wakes. The books tell me I'm ruining her for life and she'll never learn to be a good sleeper without me.
Any practical advice? I'm willing to stay up, get up, whatever, at night. But man, I would love to sleep more than 3 hour stretches, too.