M.C.
My daughters are 12 and 14 years old and I am going through similar issues with my 12 year old. I am a single working Mom so I am very worried about the after school hours. As some of the other moms have pointed out, this is the riskiest time for then.
Yesterday my 12 year old skipped swim practice after school to spend time at the school with her boyfriend and 2 other kids. So I made an appointment with her school counselor for tomorrow to come up with a plan for her teachers and swim coach to communicate with me when she doesn't show up for practice or is late to class or not doing her work or talking too much (these are other issues she is having). I am going to either limit her cell phone use or take her phone away completely until she can win back this privilege with good behavior. I plan to write out my expectations for her behavior and what privileges she will loose and have to win back so it is very clear to her. There are other privileges she can lose but my ultimate threat to her is that if she does not comply, I will take time off work and go with her to every class and swim practice until she is convinced that she must follow the rules. I heard of another mother who did this and she only had to go to school with her daughter one day.
A few months ago I had a problem with her messaging boys on myspace that she didn't know and making plans to meet them. I took away her computer privileges for a few weeks until she agreed to give me her password so that I could have full access to her myspace account so I can see all of what she is writing and what messages she is getting. I have a laptop computer so it was easy for me to simply take it with me to work. I didn't have her delete the account because she is sneaky enough that she would have probably gone behind my back and set up a secret profile.
Reasoning doesn't work with her because my 12 year old thinks she knows everything already. She keeps insisting that she isn't going to have sex, but I know how it can easily happen when the girl isn't planning on it. She has seen those TV shows about sexual predators, but she thinks it won't happen to her. Her older half sisters are in their early 20s and both of them first had sex in middle school! They now see that it was a mistake and have talked with my girls about it but it still doesn't get through to her. She doesn't think it will happen to her.
My 14 year daughter is a completely different kid. She has given me plenty of white hairs over the years with other issues, but she is very honest and open with me. So she helps keep her sister accountable when they are home together.
It is good that you are concerned about her. Too many kids are allowed to do whatever they want. You have to be strong and make the rules and know that she will be mad at you for it but it is important. When I am questioning whether I am doing the right thing I discuss it with other moms at work. Their support helps me do the hard thing. I do remind her that I am disciplining her because I love her and want what is the best for her.
Another thing that can help is to get her involved in other activities. Is there something she would want to do during those after school hours like a sport at school or a dance class? Does your church have a good youth group? These are other things you can do.
I am hoping that this is just a phase she is going through and she will be more reasonable once she reaches high school age. My 14 year old became more reasonable after starting high school. But I am also preparing for the possibility that she will continue giving me trouble until she is grown. It is our most important job in life, so we have to do whatever it takes to get our kids raised as best as we can.
Good luck. Pray for me and I'll pray for you.
Another suggestion is to check with your insurance to see if they are paying for the HPV vaccine and get her vaccinated. This won't help with her current issues but it will help keep her from having abnormal pap smears and biopsies in the future. My girls are getting the first shot tomorrow.