A.J.
I tend to just not focus on the "actual item by item price". Of course the organic version of things is pretty much always WAY MORE expensive. And even going to various sources to scout everything out takes time and gas money. I just embrace the prices (I can tell when things are organic or not, and like you, have found the good sources) and cut our costs ELSEWHERE in our budget.
Yes, our milk is much more expensive than our neighbor's milk, but I don't go the the salon-I do my own nails. Boom. Saved a bundle. Yes, the organic veggies in my cart are more than the others, but we have NO BEVERAGES or packaged food in our cart-we drink water and don't eat meat. Once in a blue moon, we splurge for the hormone free grass fed organic chicken...or some Pepperoni Paul Newman's pizza...but we eat so little of the meat products-the cost is not really an issue. We share one car that is paid off, we don't have any TV service, we barley buy any new clothes, we get all our books at the library, we don't buy toys, we rarely eat out....and our healthy groceries are expensive. It's all about priorities.
When people are ALWAYS focused on getting the VERY CHEAPEST stuff, that's how terrible industries (Wal Mart) get out of control. Sometimes it's about buying lesser quantities of better things from local shops. I understand when a family is so poor that their budget can't get any leaner, they can't opt for the expensive groceries, but lots of people waste plenty of money and then claim organic food is ridiculous. The more we support those products, the more people will grow to those standards, and the prices will improve. Good work!
Sorry, didn't answer question...I guess we cut costs elsewhere. Also, I stock up on the organic products (cans, boxes) we buy when they are on sale and avoid them when they're not.