Well, I don't have either of these, so I can't compare them. My comment is just to make sure you know neither of these toys or any other electronic system is really all that "educational" despite their claims. (This has been well documented). I'm not saying they are terible, I'm sure some kids like them, but I think my dollars are better spent on something like toys that kids can build with or pretend-- play tools, play food, legos, blocks, puzzles, trains, trucks, books, etc. Kids will learn their colors and numbers and whatnot much better from these types of play with adults. I know video games are a fact of life these days but babies and toddlers do not need these products.