S.,
I'm soooo sorry your first birth was so difficult. It really grieves my heart that so many women end up with such a trial, when birth can be a great experience. I hope that you have been able to work through that trauma--if not, you and your husband should. I don't know why you ended up with a c-section; it may have been legit, or sadly it may not have. My best recommendation is that you really research all of the things that caused you to go down that path, starting at the beginning: you and your husband's knowledge and philosophy of birth, your doctor or midwife (attitude, history, philosophy of birth, choices or demands of you or your birth--ie: did your doctors rush things), your diet (see the "No-Risk" pregnancy diet--Dr. Tom Brewer at www.blueribbonbaby.org), what interventions you may have had, genetic problems/complications, benefits or risks of drugs, whether you induced or not, assistance in labor or a chaotic experience. Go down the list and see what may have gone wrong...This will help you in adjusting your choices or deciding if you can/should have more babies.
Having a VBAC is a great way to go; I think you can still have children, but you may have to make different choices to get there. If your doctor was poor (only 10-15% of c-sections are legit--the rest are due to unneccessary interventions), you may need to find someone new--honestly, I recommend a midwife and homebirth, for prenatal care at least; you can always switch to an OB later. If you read the studies in British Medical Journal, women who have homebirths have less problems and better outcomes. Sadly, the U.S. is listed as 30th of all industrialized countries for good outcomes of birth (defined as least amount of morbidity and mortality of both mom and baby). We are very quickly moving toward being one of the worst places of top nations to have a baby. The CDC admitted that there is a high probability of the death rate of mothers during labor, delivery or postpartem is 4x higher than recorded b/c only 21 states record that women died during birth on their death certificates! Check out World Health Organizations' (WHO) information on best and worst places to have babies. Unfortunately, the majority of women do not know that you are 3x more likely to die from a planned c-section than vaginal birth. Some medical people will argue this until they're blue in the face (with no evidence-based research to back them), but the U.S. is earning a not-so-good track record internationally. There is some very good RESEARCH-BASED evidence that states why we're having so many problems in the U.S. A lot of these problems can be avoided, if you know what they are and what to stay away from.
As for a homebirth or birth center, talk to a midwife, she can let you know, based on your history, whether you would be too high risk or not. Read "Ina May's Guide to Childbirth" by Ina May Gaskin. She runs a Birth Center in Tennessee and they have the best birth statistics in the U.S.A and much of the world (healthiest moms and babies, least amount of complications). Talk and pray with your husband to see if you are peaceful with stopping or if you would like to try again and what REALLY is the best place for you and your baby to be born. Birth is one of the greatest experiences for women; you will remember it the rest of your life--and it will either scar you, or bring you joy. I hope, for your sake, that you get to experience the latter.
Here's what the American Academy of Family Physicians said about VBAC, puplished 2005... http://www.annfammed.org/cgi/data/3/4/378/DC1/1
And what the British Medical Journal published about whether homebirths are safe or not...
http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/330/7505/1416...
Also, you can rent "The Business of Being Born" from Netflix, which is a documentary-type film on birth in America; this gives a lot of food for thought and is a good starting place.
Best of luck!
J., Birth Advocate