Not Sure of My Question, but Maybe a Request for Moms of Too-friendly 4 Yr Olds?
Updated on
August 13, 2010
B.Z.
asks from
Streamwood, IL
4
answers
I brought my 3 year old son to my hubby's corporate softball game after a 95 degree day walking around the zoo. I actually looked forward to letting him play in the dirt on his own while I kicked back and watched the game. A very friendly little 4 year old girl came over to play. I found it odd that she talked to me instead of my son, but whatever... she asked me his name, does he want to play, why does he do that, etc. I directed her to ask him. Instead of talking with my son, she talked with me about her nail polish, her baby sister, her new dress, her grandpa, etc. I was friendly enough at this point. That is... until she was standing in front of me, next to me, or ON MY LAP. I was thinking, "What the heck is wrong here, and where is the parent?!?!?" I did my best to ignore her politely.
My son engaged her finally. She hit my son with sticks. I stepped in and explained that they could pretend, but no touching each other with sticks. She hit him again, and my son whacked her. I took away the sticks.
The mosquitos were bad. She told me all about her bites from the weekend trip to grandpa's, and she thought that she needed bug spray. I directed her to ask her mother for some bug spray. She went to her mother. This is how I found out who was the mom, and I realized that she could not even see her daughter when she was by me. She was talking to a couple of players from the other team at 3rd base. I was increasingly pissed off. The little girl came back and said that her mother said yes. I was confused, then I realized that she wanted to use my bug spray. So I sprayed her. That wasn't enough for her because 2 minutes later she asked for more bug spray. I told her to ask her mother to put some on her. She left for awhile. I stewed, thinking how annoyed I was getting. I would love to visit with my hubby's team while my son played on his own. I was jealous of that other mom’s freedom at the moment. Hmm… to live life so carelessly.
I hate to say that the evening only worsened. They did go off and on playing together, but I felt the need to watch closely. At one point, during chase, she ran into the parking lot. I was frustrated... instead of correcting her, I congratulated my son for staying on the grass. After a few occasions of her doing something "naughty" and me praising my son for not doing that, she got vicious. She was scratching him, taking things from his hands, using a mean tone, etc. My son was increasingly rude to her, including an instance of teasing her with the rock he found. He held it out for her but didn’t let her see or touch it. My son got really mean to her, saying things like, "I don't want to play with you!" I corrected his behavior in front of her, saying things like, “Even if she is saying mean things to you, that doesn’t make it right for you to say mean things back to her. Just ignore her. Let’s go for a walk on our own.” We physically left the area, walking to our car near right field (the opposite corner of the field where the mom was standing). I was disgusted that the parent did not stop her 4 year old from following us. I could see the mom, but there were trees and bushes blocking the view between the kids and the little girl’s mom.
Thankfully, the game ended. (Ugh… they went an extra inning… torture!) I was so annoyed and ready to go home. I felt like I missed an opportunity to mold that child in some way, to help her along in life. She begged for attention, and she needed some guidance with manners. I kicked myself for not addressing the situation with the mom. Sadly, after thinking WWJD, I decided that I should have remained patient and used the situation as a learning opportunity for everyone.
Thank you for some perspective on this whole situation. I am typically nonconfrontational, but your responses gave me some confidence to address this issue directly with the mother next time. Also, handling this situation appropriately with my son was the most challenging issue. I'm torn about whether to allow him to speak rudely to someone when he's frustrated with them. I encourage him to be direct, but the teasing and rude tone are just that... rude.
Thank you again!
More Answers
P.M.
answers from
Portland
on
What an interesting experience, B.. A case of sibling rivalry among non-siblings.
I think you nailed it: the child begged for attention (which you generously provided), and she needed some guidance with manners (which you didn't offer, but probably could have, considering how little guidance her mom was giving her). If you weren't knocked off balance by this miniature steam-roller (and possibly by your expectation that her mom should be handling it), then you might have decided more easily where your boundaries should lie.
I feel sorry for the poor kid – it sounds like her mommy is not particularly into nurturing or guiding her. I've seen that happen. And I'm sure I've been guilty of it myself on occasion. I'll bet we all have.
Thanks for sharing your provocative story.
4 moms found this helpful
Report This
K.L.
answers from
Erie
on
Don't beat yourself up so badly. A little girl was starved for attention, through no fault of yours. You (and your son) gave her an hour of your time. Could you have given more? Perhaps, but it is unlikely that you would have built a long-term relationship with this complete stranger. She saw you model positive parenting skills - although she may long to see her mother do the same, at least she knows that your type of love exists :)
As for the jealousy thing, I hear ya! There are plenty of times when I'm resentful of the carefree lives that others appear to lead. Then I remember that I'm doing what I believe is best for my children and my family, and I can see the results when I step back to look. We can all look over that fence to the greener grass, but we need to look at the weeds that are growing there too ;)
3 moms found this helpful
Report This
S.S.
answers from
Chicago
on
Obviously mom doesn't pay any attention to her and you are a good mom yourself, thoughtful in every way. Sadly there are so many situations like that. Happily you don't have many ball games to go to. I am always amazed at how little value parents place on that little life. There are too many nuts on this earth to not pay attention to where your children are. So many things happening that are unsafe. I do not have to enlist a visual of all the horror stories but those are the people who are screaming and whining about how come their child was hit by a car or kidnapped, when before they really just didn't care. I am so sorry to hear you had to go through that. And sorry for your son. But most of all I pity that little girl because her life will continue to be like that, starved for affection. God bless people like you who still care.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
I.G.
answers from
Seattle
on
I have encountered similar situations.
First of all it's not mean for your son to tell her that he doesn't want to play with her. It should have ended right there. I would have even stepped in if she didn't leave at that point and said "you know honey, John doesn't want to play anymore, so you should go back to your mommy" Period. Every time she comes back, tell her: "Sorry, but we are done playing with you, please stay with your mommy or play by yourself".
If that doesn't work deliver her to her mom and tell the mom that you can't look after her daughter and would prefer that she kept an eye on her...