I saw this post a few days ago but just haven't had the time to pour my thoughts into it.
Please understand that I am speaking as a Kindergarten teacher...but I "retired" when our oldest was born. That was 14 years ago.
As a teacher, I still made the choice not to send our kids to a formal pre school. ( husband was totally on board as well) I personally felt it was a waste of money.
I am home full time. Why pay someone else to provide the experiences and education that I can do for free? Children do not NEED preschool to become successful in school...or life for that matter. Studies show that once kids reach 3rd grade, you can not differentiate between students that did or did not attend preschool.
I have read many books regarding child development. I just don't see the hard facts that make me see the need to put young children in school before they are truly developmentally, socially or emotionally ready. 5 years old has been the age to begin institutional education for a reason. Overall, children that age are developmentally ready to begin the process.
I totally understand the need for parents who work full time to find the best possible solution to fit their family's circumstances. The experiences at pre school /day care are needed because mom or dad cannot physically be there to do it.
I take my role as a mother very seriously and look at my child's needs in the moment, yet also think to the future. What skills and knowledge do they need to be a well rounded teenager,young adult and adult.
The world can be your child's classroom. It just takes some creativity to find the moments and experiences for your child. Take for example a simple trip to the grocery store. At the grocery store we talk about budgeting, healthy eating, price comparison, following directions and then I have them ask questions to the produce worker or ask a clerk where the restroom is. We attend church. There they learn many things both secular and non secular. They learn that there are times mommy and daddy are not in charge and they need to respect their elders. They need to sit, be quiet and raise a hand to be called upon.
Each of my kids were involved in a mommy preschool the year before formal Kindergarten. I found a group of moms who would like to co op preschool with me. We rotated the teaching at our homes, used a credible curriculum and planned little field trips. This curriculum cost very little and we split the cost. We would rotate the teaching so when were not teaching we had some "me" time. I think I taught two times a week for two weeks then off for 6 weeks.
Our kids are in 8th,6th and 2nd grade today. They are very successful, social and outgoing. They perform in music and sports, are great readers and loved by their teachers. They are also leaders among their peers.
I wanted them to have opportunities to play and learn social order among their peers. Too often the scheduled activities don't allow for collaboration, free thinking and exploration. Kids are told where to sit, what team to be on, what to do, when to be done etc. Kids don't ask questions..they just wait to be told what to do. Studies find that this is seeping into the workforce. Heck, my husband sees it as he has hired and fired people. He cannot sit over their shoulders to tell them step by step instructions. We are losing our initiative to try new things, to innovate , to problem solve, to trouble shoot etc.
I do not regret for one moment the extra days and years I was able to be with our kids at home. But, it is not so much about me wanting to be with them. It is about them needing the security at a young age of being home more, being mentored by a loving parent and feeling safe and LOVED. I totally believe that a child that has a loving and nurturing foundation will become very successful. (and I am not talking about a big paycheck)
I recently read the book, "How Children Succeed- Grit, Curiosity, and the Hidden Power of Character", by Paul Tough. I thoroughly enjoyed the book. It really sums up our approach to parenting. I want our kids to explore the world around them, have freedom to be who they want to be, have opportunities to make mistakes and fail and then get back up and try again, and most of all to have a desire to help others and serve their fellowman.
You got waaaay more than you were asking for. I just see so many parents stressed out and feeling pressured into getting their little ones in the "best" preschool, best school, tons of extra curricular activities, tutoring ,etc for fear they might set their kids up for failure in life.
Too many kids today are over scheduled, stressed out, anxiety riddled and broken. And for what??? Just to keep adding to that resume in mom and dads heads for the college application. Parents are also feeling the pressure to keep up with their own peers and all the activities the friends' kids are in. It is insane!!
I suggest watching the movies Race to Nowhere and Waiting for Superman. It has opened my eyes to the changes in our education system and the ridiculous pressure parents feel today but most of all the pressure heaped on the shoulders of our young kids. I guess it hits home because we have had some students locally commit suicide due to the pressure they feel academically at school, from parents and peers. So sad!
Ok..I am off my soapbox. Take what you want and dismiss the rest.
In a nutshell. Our kids did not go to formal preschool. They did not struggle aside from what is normal. Yes, they were and are successful. No, I wouldn't have done anything differently. Except maybe not so many "field trips" to the donut shop! (hee...hee!)