A.L.
I had the same problem you are. I hurt so bad I could hardly stand it. I did use Soothies, too, and they worked pretty good for me. With my first child, I got them at Kaiser. I think they have a Lactation Department (there is a place where you can rent pumps and they will probably have the Soothies there). With my second child, I got them at Babies 'R' Us. I don't think they are all that expensive there but when you are hurting and need a little relief, you will probably pay anything.
Good Luck!! and I hope this helps.