This is my family's recipe handed down from great-grandma. A little different from most others in that we dont cook the ketchup in/with/on it, but put it on when it's on our plates/in sandwiches (yum yum)
Mollie's Meatloaf (I can almost tell it from memory)
3 lbs beef
1 lb pork
1 cup bread crumbs (dry - or cracker crumbs)
1/2 c onions (finely chopped is better)
3 tsp salt
1/4 tsp pepper
1 cup milk
(Squish it all together in a large bowl.)
Shape into 2-3 loaves. (I prefer to do 4)
put on rack in shallow pan
bake 1 hr 350 degrees
baste every 15 mins with juices (? I forget to do this!)
16 servings (that's what it says!)
No ketchup, no sausage although I do use mild sausage for the pork sometimes (it's not a spicy meatloaf, and makes excellent sandwiches with the leftover slices. And yes, let it sit & cool a bit before slicing.)
I use lean ground beef in this fat-conscious world but I think the fat cooking out from the meat may be actually what makes it hold together a little better and not so dry/crumbly at the end. Also, I think eggs mixed into foods help hold it together. I thought it had an egg in the recipe but it doesn't, I may have added it before, I don't remember.
Also, put them into muffin tins - it's fun for my son to have a meat-muffin instead of slices on his plate sometimes, and so easy to figure out how many to heat up for leftovers (as you can see, my recipe is for 4 lbs of meat, and it's just the 3 of us, haha. I LOVE leftovers & freezer meals so I don't have to cook every single day!) Plus it spends less time in the oven heating up the house!
Just read through the other recipes. eyew, please dont add green peppers, that RUINS it for me! But if you like it, go right ahead! grated veggies sound good though. As mentioned, we like ours cooked without any of the tomato stuff, and add ketchup on ourselves when eating.
Maybe moist bread crumbs could be the problem? I will let my bread crusts dry out (either whole or broken up into crumbs) then process them till they're crumbs and ready to use for this or whatever. Or use smashed saltines.