Hello! I am one of "those" face painters. :) I want to share my perspective:
#1 Whatever you do, DO NOT use acrylic paints on skin!!! It is very dangerous--allergic reactions are extremely common, if a piece flakes off and gets in the eye you risk blindness, it WILL stain the skin, it is painful and tedious to remove, and if you top it off with craft glitter and a piece of that sharp glass gets in the eye it will cut the cornea!
#2 if you go the route of letting someone artistic with no experience paint on the kids, be sure to get them professional paints. Here are some brands to choose from: Snazaroo, Wolfe, Diamond FX, Paradise, and Kryolan.
Don't forget body safe polyester glitter!
#3 The reason a professional face artist costs $100 an hour is because that artist spends much time and money to learn and buy Safe Products, to sit at the feet of masters and learn how to use the medium of a Face, to be quick, professional, fun, safe, and to produce designs that the child will remember for a long time. Face painting is a full time job, a career and a calling, and supports the family of the painter. During hours not spent working at a precious child's party, they are pursuing quality, safety, practice, professionalism and more parties! :)
Suffice it to say, they cost $100 because they are worth $150! You get what you pay for.
#4 Many face painters, and I am one, offer coupons, specials, and discounts, depending on the situation! All you have to do is ask! :)
Call or email and open a dialogue, you will be happy you did.
I agree with your call, however, that most four year olds won't want to sit still for an elaborate $10 design. Never fear! All professional face painters have in their aresenal: Half Faces, Quick versions of Full Faces, and Cheek Art! Be warned, however, that Cheek art takes a lot more time and stillness than any of the others because of the concentrated detail. It's a misconception that smaller is quicker.
If you email me, I will offer you a discount simply because you are a mamapedia mom! :) I can paint 14-20 faces in an hour that look memorable, and my paints are the safest you can buy.
Good luck and have fun whatever you choose to do!
~A. Kirsch
SnazzyFaces.net
____@____.com