A.B.
My daughter (20 months) won't sleep at night either. It takes her 1 - 2 hours every night! There are 2 things I do.... Number one) If she is crying or yelling, I will go to her and ask what's wrong, rub her head, tell her to sleep.... basically do what it takes to calm her, but do not take her out of the crib. Once she is in bed, she is there to stay. No matter what. I always tell her nicely but firmly to go to sleep. Of course, this can last for hours, so I only do it if she is really crying. If she is just awake, I leave her alone.
Number 2) To keep her happy while she is alone.... She has a teddy bear and blanket that she LOVES. She talks to her bear forever. She also has an aquarium soother, so she presses the button and plays the music. This allows her to be awake for the 2 hours without driving us crazy and preventing us from sleeping.
i was worried about allowing her to be up for so long, but all the advice i got is that as long as she is happy, what's the difference?
So, maybe get her some approriate crib things to keep her happy. If she is going to be awake anyway, it might as well not make you or her unhappy. But whether you get her toys or not, I still suggest that as much as you go in her room to calm her, do not take her out of the crib. She needs to get the message that once it's bed time... there is no other option.