F.T.
We just had to do the same switch at the beginning of the year, and I was extremely concerned b/c I also had delivered at Prentice and love my old doc... That said, I have gotten some good recommendations from friends - Dr. Jacob Saleh works out of Evanston Hospital and comes highly recommended by a friend who delivered with him. I went to see him for my annual exam and he was great - and his nurse is fantastic. Actually, it turns out that he had trained my old doctor... small world! I will likely have my next baby through him.
Since I live in Lincoln Square, I am also going to set up an appointment with the midwives group at Swedish Covenant because I've heard amazing things and I live about 5 minutes from there... Seems like that will be a bonus since I'll have my son at home whenever I end up having our second babe. At Swedish, I've also gotten recs for Dr. Maureen Brennan and Dr. Therese Wos.
One last recommendation from a friend that I can pass along was Dr. Amy Hoffman at IL Masonic. She had a great experience with her.
If you are looking for a pediatrician, I can recommend my son's doctor, Andy Sagan. He used to be the director of a big practice at Northwestern and is now the director of pediatrics at Swedish Covenant. I love that he has so much experience, and continues his affiliation with Children's, so if anything ever happened with my son, that's where we'd go. Some people don't like his style (very direct and opinionated), but for my peace of mind, I can deal with his personality (and I actually like him for it!).
Good luck - you'll find someone you love!