A.G.
I have good friends who go to Chalice Christian and would go myself if it weren't 40 minutes away. I'm not sure if by "not overly religious" you mean not not focusing on God and faith, or whether you mean not the kind of in-your-face piousness of evangelicals. This place is definitely the former, but the opposite of the latter. If people who quote the bible in favor of obnoxious things annoy you, it's a good place :-)
http://www.chalicechristian.com/