I would try a little psychology with him... You say he appreciates a tidy house? Perfect. Ask your two older boys if they would help Mommy perform an experiment (this way they do not make my suggestion a habit). Tell them that for a couple of days, both of them, as well as you, are going to leave your hats, shoes and jackets EVERYWHERE. Make sure they are in places your husband will definitly trip over. Hats should end up in the fridge, coats on doorknobs that he uses most, etc. This will show him what it would be like if everyone were as privileged as he as far as rules go. Why should everyone else follow them if he does not have to? He should lead by example and this should show him why. Good Luck!