All my life I was in trouble for talking in class, finishing papers early, and (get this) reading ahead of the class during read alouds (I would start reading with the class, but the other kids read so slow, I would keep reading without realizing I was going ahead until the teacher called on me and I didn't know where they were). At that time, add/adhd was not regularly diagnosed. If I were in school now- I would have been "diagnosed" by teachers for sure! I have the tendency to jump from thought to thought (as you can see in most of my postings on mamasource) and I also have the tendency to take a great interest in something for a few weeks or months and then drop it like it was nothing. However, I can learn a lot in those weeks or months and retain the knowledge and apply it elsewhere. For those reasons, one of my college special ed professors told me that I probably have some condition under the autism umbrella as well as add/adhd. Well- I am here to tell you, I am fine without the diagnosis and without treatment. I was in the Talented and Gifted Program in elementary school and in honors classes in middle and high school. I finished my nursing degree before I had been out of high school for 2 years (with 2 babies to take care of along the way); I am now working on my elementary education degree and am often told by professors that I am ahead of the mainstream thinking- I am going to be the author of some great published work in the field some day- IF I can just control my writing and keep it fluid rather than jumping around. I also volunteer for a hundred little things and hear from people on a regular basis saying: how do you know so much, how do you do everything you do, how do you have an interest in so many things?... Well, I just do- that is who I am. I don't like to sit still for hours at a time and I am interested in lots of things. I don't think that means I need medication! Thank goodness add/adhd was not often diagnosed when I was a kid- I'd have been medicated and most likely would not have accomplished all that I have. I am now 24 years old- have 4 wonderful, bright children; an RN licence (I no longer use it, though); am a director of a preschool; am working towards my masters in education; run a girl scout troop; oversee the girl scout troops in my kids' school; run 3 websites (two for work, one for the kids' school); play with photography; can talk to you about nearly any subject with interest; and have time to do stuff like write long messages on this forum!!! :) My point here is this: just because one teacher thinks your daughter is not within her definition of "normal" doesn't mean anything. I am not in some peoples definition of "normal", but then for every one of those people, there are 10 telling me how great I am. Beyond that, I am happy, my kids are happy, my family is happy with where we've ended up- we don't need those other peoples definition of what or who I should be.
From the teacher front- it is still early in the year- you may want to visit (without notice, you are not the one who has to explain yourself in this situation- the school is by most rights your employees and you have every right to be showing up unannounced)- anyway- visit the class you daughter is in, as well as the other 1st grade classes. Just peek in and look at what the kids are doing. Look at the classroom. The teacher who has a perfectly quiet room is not the one for your daughter. The one who has productive noise and who's room is a little messy is most likely the right fit. Schedule a time to meet with her and interview her- then request nicely but firmly that the school change your daughters class. You have that right- continue to use it every year. At the end of this year, peek in on the 2nd grade rooms and meet with the teachers, then make a request that your daughter be placed in whatever class next year. This does go over better if you are involved with the school like PTA or volunteering sometimes, but if you can't you still have the right to decide where your daughter goes.
Just think- one whole school year of having a teacher who constantly is nitpicking at your daughter versus one whole school year of having a teacher who encourages your daughter to use her energy. What is the difference? How will it affect her attitude about school? How will it change her self-esteem?
From the parent front- this could have been me writing this post last year! My son is very bright- he was reading in the first month of kindergarten and bored most of the time. By last year (first grade), he was coming home with "red slips" from his teacher for talking in class. Well, he was talking because the finished the worksheets that are given to fill time. He is fast and was bored after he was done with the papers.
At one point he was coming home with cuts in his shirts, saying he didn't know how they got there- finally he admitted he did it while he was waiting for everyone to be done because he was bored.
We began to let him play outside a lot after school, and if he woke up early enough and got ready for school with at least 20 minutes left we let him play in the front yard before school, too. I also started walking the kids to school. This helped some. I also talked to his teacher to let her know that he was bored- in our case, he had a great teacher who was slightly unorganized (how a teacher should be, it means they have lots of ideas and are constantly changing things up for variety and to get the best lesson in) anyway, I knew it wasn't her fault, she had a class full of students with different levels of ability. She looked for an answer to challenge him and found another teacher who was able to bring him into her classroom with a few other kids 2 days a week to do large activities and projects that built on the things they had been taught.
It may not be that your daughter is showing great signs of being gifted- sometimes the kids are gifted in areas other than academics. Sometimes they are academically gifted, but it does not show because they rush through their paper work or don't pay a lot of attention to it because it is boring to them. And maybe she is not gifted- maybe she just (gasp!) can't sit still all day! I know that is not how kids ought to be, but hey, that is how some teachers want them to be- so I go back to the idea of finding that teacher that is slightly messy and lots of fun.
One last thought to my book I am writing here- my son is going into second grade this year (his first day was today!) and tonight when I pick him up, I will be giving his new teacher a sodoku book for kids that she can let him play in after he has finished work. I will also be in regular contact with her to see what they are learning about and then letting him do more research on it at home; magazines and kids internet pages with info are great- they turn boring school topics into fun and interesting games for after school. This also lets them be more interested during the school day.
Hope something here helps!
~T.~