S.J.
Yep - toothpaste has always worked for me. It doesn't "get rid of it" necessarily, but seems to "draw out" the yuck inside faster and thereby speeding up the process. Paste, no gel.
I also am a fan of salicylic acid treatment. Neutrogena has a GREAT line. Try the scrub, then topical gel. It works, and fast.
Good luck!