S.T.
dear gods, stay away from the $10 an hour person. that's a nightmare waiting to happen.
i've taught lessons for years and i approve of your barn's policies. are they a little on the conservative side? yeah. but that's okay. if you saw the insurance rates for riding schools you'd understand.
and it's not just the money. one bad experience can turn a kid off from horses for life. horses are prey animals. they're big and strong and they spook easily. you have GOT to be well educated in how to handle them. the horses too deserve to be well-treated by the riding establishment, and that means carefully instructing the students so the patient schoolmasters aren't expected to deal with the sudden movements and harsh handling that uneducated people deal out to them.
if you want your child to progress faster, get private lessons. i personally much prefer to teach private lessons. groups are difficult and unwieldy and you always have this issue with some being impatient to move on while others are timid and want to slow down.
if you've ever watched a horse enduring someone trotting before they're ready you'll understand. those reins are attached to a living MOUTH. if the rider doesn't know how to balance herself in the saddle and keep a light contact on the reins (used for steering and communication NOT to keep the rider in the saddle) that poor beast gets socked in the chops over and over as the klutz in the saddle uses the reins to stay aboard.
not cool.
be glad you've got a safe, cautious, conservative establishment that will teach your kids the basics right from the gitgo.
khairete
S. (longtime riding instructor and trainer)