M.S.
OK this might sound strange. My husband and I had an issue with a couple of mice when living with my dad. Peanut butter seemed to never work on the traps, even though I've seen success with it before. My husband was eating a can of Beanie Weenies one day and said Hmm, wonder if this would attract them?(No clue why he thought of that) So he dripped just a little bit of the juice from the can on the trap, that night we caught a mouse. He did the same thing the next night and we caught the second and final one we'd seen. Strange, but it worked. I don't know if the mouse could smell it more than the peanut butter or what, but I was happy....no more mice! lol