Just do a garage sale. I don't like Craig's list either - some people say they want to buy an item, you make an appt to show the item, and they either don't show up at all after you changed your personal schedule to accomoodate them or they do show up and decide not to purchase after you given them numerous pics and a detailed description of the item. I found it's not worth the aggravation.
My tip for the garage sale - is FRIDAY 1/2 day and Saturday early, till noon. On Friday, most of your items will more than likely be gone - you will attract the serious garage saler crowd. Also, save yourself the time of pricing items. People will always ask for a lower price anyways so there is not point on pricing items. I always schedule Salvation Army or another charity to come pick up the items on that Saturday or monday afterwards so I don't have them around the house or if it's not inconvenient, you can take them to the drop off stations around the city.
Good Luck!