Photo by: Willy D

This Generation

Photo by: Willy D

Aidan asked me last week if he could have a Facebook account. He’s 9.

It shouldn’t surprise anyone that my answer was a resounding no.

The world my kids are growing up in is such a different one than I grew up in. Every generation claims that, I know. Every set of parents always thinks that it’s harder to have kids in the time they exist in than ever before.

And I’d make the argument that every set of parents is right. (Well, maybe except for the Depression generation….it had to be pretty awful to raise a child back then, and compared to those times, the next generation had it easier.)

The truth is that science and technology has always outpaced the ability of humans to deal with it. We come up with bigger, faster, better before we quite know what we are going to do with it. And we raise our children in an environment of constant evolution and adaptation.

Think about it…think about all the things that our kids have become accustomed to that didn’t even exist 10 or 20 years ago, or if they did, they weren’t in wide use by masses in society. The personal computer, internet, cell phones, satellites, DVRs, ipods, gaming systems, GPS navigation systems, social networking, ebay, craigslist.

When I had a report due for school and it had to be typed, I actually had to type it. On a typewriter. At some point, I had a fancy word processor machine. I finally got a computer in my junior year of college.

When we were kids, if you wanted to get a hold of someone, you had to have access to a land line. If you were out, you had to find a payphone and actually have change in your pocket. If they were on the phone, you got a busy signal. If they weren’t home, you could leave a message only if they had an answering machine. You couldn’t just call them 24/7.

We only had the tv channels 2-13 when I was a kid and I was the remote control. If you missed seeing something live on tv, you missed it. Period. Music came on radios and cassette tapes and eventually CDs. You listened to the same 12 songs over and over, your CDs skipped when you tried to exercise with them.

We had Commodore 64s and only if you were really lucky, an Atari. If you were driving somewhere you weren’t familiar with, you took a map with you. If you wanted to chat with friends, you had to do it in person. If you needed to sell some stuff, you had a garage sale.

It is an entirely different world they live in.

Everyone it seems is instantly accessible now. It takes far less effort to stay in contact with people than it used to, which definitely has pluses and minuses. Everything you do anymore is out there for the world to see. Your accomplishments and your mistakes, public information.

The thing about technology, at least in this moment in time, is that it makes communication easier, but it doesn’t actually make it better. Texting will never be as good as talking. Online chatting will never substitute for an actual conversation. It seems the more connected we are, the less in touch we are.

In some ways, all this actually makes us more isolated.

Adults have a hard enough time grasping that. And kids, our kids, are growing up in a world where this is the norm.

I want my kids to develop their personal interaction skills before they delve into the world of leading virtual lives. Before they become always accessible and instantly connected, I want them to figure out that sometimes being away from that all is better.

Sometimes you don’t want to be found. Sometimes you don’t want everyone to know what your status is. Sometimes you don’t need to share that all with the world. Sometimes you need to learn better first.

This world we live in today is a hard one because I have to raise my kids at home and in the public eye all at once. They have to grow up both as individuals and as members of a constantly more interconnected society. They have to be infinitely more aware of everyone and everything around them, because someone is always watching.

I know that at some point, I will give in to the world we live in. I’m not delusional. I know already that Aidan is better at using a lot of this new technology than I will ever be. It’s second nature to him, to the children of this generation, because they have always had it. At some point, my kids will have cells phones and email accounts and Facebook profiles. First though, I think I’ll let them just be kids for a bit longer.

I’m a mean mom. I told him no.

Kelly is a doula, a photographer, a woman, a wife and a mom of 4 incredible kids.

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

38 Comments

I agree, technology breeds new challenges. It also makes life easier. There's two sides.
I won't let my kids on FB either, but I easily pass the blame to FB rules (have to be 13), which are from federal regulations. Too many risks to kids with immautre reasoning skills!
Yes, teach kids to interact in person. Teach them also how to use technology appropriately...

See entire comment

Here's a slightly different view: I absolutely agree that young kids should not have a facebook account; You must know your teen well enough to know when/ if they are ready. Bullying... can occur via facebook, and you won't know unless they tell you. Reading their facebook info. is perceived as reading their diary back in "The day". I have a 17 yr. old son with ASPERGER'S SYNDROME (AUTISM spectrum) who started using facebook when he was diagnosed, at 15 1/2 yrs. old...

See entire comment

You're not mean. Mom's always feel guilty, way more guilty than Dads. SO next time make your partner tell him "no."
He probably just wants to play all those games, which are actually a lot more docile than some of the other crap he could be playing. Maybe you could start a family facebook account and give him limitied access, then you've got a motivational tool as well. He's got to earn points doing chores, homework whatever before he can get his computer time...

See entire comment

In a world that is increasingly saturated with media and technology, I as a preschool teacher struggle to help children find a way to separate their "screen life" from real life...

See entire comment

I agree with you. In my house one hour of electronics is earned each day. My almost 9 year old daughter may play on her computer that isn't connected to the internet learning games I have chosen or play Wii. We don't have any sit on you butt games, all physical activity so far for the Wii. I have already warned my family not to give us any worthless games. That I will just exchange them for learning ones...

See entire comment

Let me start by saying that I have raised my three children and my grandson who is now 20. When our grandson came into our care, we were confident in our parenting abilities as we had three great kids. However, we were quickly educated to the present and how technology plays a part in raising children today. When our children were preteen and teen, I began to have concern as to what they were watching on TV. They yearned to watch John Belushi on SNL so I started watching it with them...

See entire comment

Re. Teacher Hazel Wheeler's post: Hazel, you summed it up perfectly!
Everyone needs to read your post (on 10/16)!!

More of us mothers should be brave enough to actually raise our kids rather than conforming to what all the other kids have.
I was raised with a Dad who was a vice president of Marketing at Mattel Toys when I was growing up. He would bring home a Liddle Kiddles doll and put it up in his closet and give me allowance each week. When I would finally earn it, he would give it to me. I felt good knowing I earned it. He felt good knowing he had taught me you have to work for what you get...

See entire comment

Love this! I am so there with you. My oldest is almost 14 and I still won't let him have a FB account. He has a cell phone, but only to keep in touch with his dad and me when he's not at home - he's not allowed to give his number out or use it to text or call friends. He has an email account, and I reserve the right to periodically check his incoming and outgoing email, and he is aware of this...

See entire comment

LOL, yes, I'm quite often the "mean mom". My almost 14-year old daughter is not allowed to have a facebook account. She and her now 11 year old sister each have a cell phone, but it is closely monitored. I hesitated on the phones, but they travel 1k miles away for visitations and I wanted them to be able to get ahold of "home". Monitored or not, there are too many creepy people out there...and I will continue to be the "mean mom" if means keeping my kids safe.

I understand your concern. I tried to keep technology as far from my son for as long as I could. He got his Facebook account last year when he was 16. Sadly... his father let him have a "MySpace" account sooner than that but luckly... we both keep a close eye on it and the only "friends" he had outside of family we real kids he knew at school and he could prove they were real human beings and not strangers with phoney pictures...

See entire comment

I was just debating our decision to not let our 11 year old join Facebook. I know a LOT of his friends are on there. Yet I do believe rules are meant to be followed too (thankfully he is alike in that manner). He does have a cell phone but it is a very basic model and only to be used for emergencies...

See entire comment

The decision has to be very personal in order to fit the family. I agree with Julie that teaching censorship as an everyday fact of life when they are young makes it much easier to keep tabs on their online activity when they are in their teens. My oldest are adults, with some living at great distances. My 7-year-old daughter now has a Facebook account w/ me, but not under a real name. She does not have a password to turn the computer on, nor does she know the password to FB...

See entire comment

I'm a mean mom too!!!!! My 11 year old is not permitted to have a FB account. My 14yo does...and my husband and I spend much time monitoring it. We've called other school parents + the school principal when necessary to follow up on inappropriate posts. Our son sometimes beats us to the punch...tells his friends to watch their language on their posts b/c his parents check...

Stay strong!

Good for you, Kelly!
However, sooner or later, you're going to have to let Aidan have a FaceBook account, so here are some suggestions:
1. Location: computers, TVs, games players, etc. should not be in the kids' rooms. Ideally, they should be in a lockable cupboard, or a separate room with a lock if your house is big enough. Otherwise, they should be in a public area, such as the living room, where you can see and hear what the kids are up to.
2...

See entire comment

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all