J.B.
with my daughters 1st and 2nd bday i didnt do any games at all. i had the party at the park so the kids could play. her 2nd bday theme was wow wow wubbzy (which isnt in stores yet so i had to emprovise lol). for the loot bags i used paper lunch sacks and taped a wubbzy caracter on it. in them were - star shape sunglasses, fun twisty straw, 2 suckers (i didnt want a lot of candy either), coloring page, noise maker (horn), hand clapper, a balloon, party hat and a little thing of bubbles. all these things i got at party city in bulk so it was pretty cheap. i made sure that what was in the bags were ok for all ages comming (which were 20months to 6 years). dont worry about looking cheap your child is turning 1 and he cant do that much lol.
my inlaws thought it was dumb of me and my husband to pay for a bakery to hand make our daughters cupcake cake allergy friendly because i child comming had food allergies (milk eggs and nuts). all i told her is that i wanted everyone to be happy and to enjoy the cake not single one child out because she couldnt have cake. i did minimal dedorations only a happy birthday banner and balloon center pieces with balloon weights from the dollar store.
just do what you think is enough :)