Hello~
My daughter (who is now 10 - almost 11) has flown 2-4 times per year since the week after she turned 5.
She flies American Airlines on a direct flight from Chicago O'Hare to Oklahoma City. It's a direct flight and is about 2 1/2 hours "gate to gate" from take-off to landing.
We have NEVER had a problem and my daughter actually LOVES to fly by herself. I get my own 'boarding pass', we go through security and I take her to one gate where the gate agent escorts her to her seat. After they land the gate agent escorts her off the plane where her dad is waiting at the gate for her. Also you are required to stay in the airport until the plane is off the ground - not just away from the gate.
Typically, they seat her in the first row of coach (even if the ticketing agent doesn't do this they will switch them when you check in. Once we book an unaccompanied minor seat they block out the seats next to her unless the plane is full. I think in over 5 years of flying 2-4 times each year (so approx 15 times) she has had to sit with someone twice.
The only even sorta bad experiences that she had was
1. she did vomit during one flight - but we always pack an extra change of clothes in her carry-on and the flight attendant was SUPER helpful and she wasn't even upset when she got off the plane.
2. We also had one time a couple years ago where the plane got to the end of the runway and sorta started to almost takeoff and then the pilot re-landed and they switched planes - so that was a nice 6 hours in O'Hare while we waited for the replacement plane. But Regan said it was "exciting" and none of the passengers even got out of sorts about it.
As far as helpful hints:
She used to take a portable DVD player & headphones with her and she would watch a movie. I just made sure she knew exactly how to work it so she could do it herself. Now she has a DS and an ipod and she can read actual books, so she hasn't taken the movies in a while. But, I would definitely recommend that. Since 2 are flying I would send ONE movie so there are no fights about what to watch.
Here's the deal about emergencies - there really truly aren't that many on airplanes. It's MUCH safer than flying (even when you count in the general public interactions....lol). I have found that when I am flying and I see how people react to unaccompanied minors other passengers are MUCH MORE TOLERANT than kids flying WITH parents - I think the protective instinct comes out. So, I would imagine if they are well-behaved kids and want to do it then would think they would be fine.
Also - most of the issues you hear about are kids who have problems on flights that change planes. American doesn't even let you fly non-direct until your kid is 8 - by then Regan would have know if she was on the wrong connection. And I think in the last 6 years I have heard of maybe 3 issues with unaccompanied minors..... WAY LESS than car accidents or kidnappings. Yet, people who DON'T do it think it's very unsafe..... it's really not.
One note- I chose American Airlines even though they have a heftier fee per kid because (at least 5 years ago) they had to request to escort an unaccompanied minor. So, I felt like it would be better than if just 'any old attendant got *stuck* with a kid'.
Also typically if it's their first flight they get to meet the pilot and tour the plane and all that *fun* stuff. So they should have a good time.
I definitely understand your concerns - for the first 2 flights she took, I cried the whole 2 1/2 hours after take-off until her dad called to say she was there.
But now I take something to read and book a mani-pedi!!!!!!!
Good Luck with your decision!
B.