You may be "stuck" with what you've got until he's 5ish. Any new flavors and textures that he hasn't had before now will get tagged as "posion" by his brain until that response shuts off in a few years. The best theory is that it's an evolutionary holdover that has kept the human race from dying out by linking a "spit it out now!!!!" response in with new flavors they haven't tasted in their breast milk & been given by mums at about the age they start getting more independent. Toddlers aren't exactly picky, they're programmed to have new flavors be as delicious as dog poop (the brain scans are really fun to look at, you can totally tell when it's an independence thing and when it's "you want me to eat what????" neurological thing). So when they stick that poisonous berry, dead bug, or pebble in their mouth... thwibbit... out it comes again. UNFORTUNATELY the companies that market "baby food" and "toddler food" stick to a bland, repetive diet. So by the time WE'RE ready for them to start experimenting... their bodies have a whole different notion of what's safe to eat, than what is really the case.
LUCKILY by flavors I'm really talking chemical signatures. So you've actually got a slightly longer list. (Ex: basil is basil whether it's in marinara, pesto, or thai food)
- Chicken
- Potatoes
- Wheat products
- "pizza sauce" : tomatoes, vinegar, oregano, etc... just look at the ingredients list for all the herbs/veggies, etc.
- Whichever pizza toppings he already eats
- Cheese (soft, non-ripened cheeses... like cheddar & mozz) Mild ones
- anything else he'll eat (like eggs? veggies? fruits?)
So you start breaking down what he eats into ingredients, and then start making dishes based on the INGREDIENTS instead of the finished dish. For example: You already know he eats chicken and carrots and wheat/bread products... so that means you can make pot pies, soups, stews, shish ka bobs, etc. And if he's eaten anything with soy in it... 1 will get you 10 he'll eat teriyaki chicken in addition to breaded chicken. Ditto if he's eaten soy and noodles separately (and if you started out with rice cereal), you can probably make asian rice noodles with dressing in addition to italian wheat noodles. And since you know he likes wheat noodles and cheese... you can probably do ANY shape noodle with alfredo, marinara, bolognese, etc. He likes mozzerella and he likes tomatoes and he likes basil (all from the pizza)... so you may find he loves tomato, fresh mozz, & pesto salad. He drinks juice (assuming apple just as a jumping off point) so he may like applesauce, pork stuffed with apple, bakes apples, apple marmelade, etc. But DO source out each and every base "flavor" in his current diet and see how much you can branch off.
What you're currently feeding him will keep him both alive, and healthy... it's just boring. Which isn't the worst thing on the planet. And you'll occasionally get lucky... because an old "acceptable" food blended with a new untried food might make the link to have the new food be yummy instead of yucky as well. Ex: If he really likes Penne (or linguine or fettucini or etc) alfredo with chicken... he may also end up loving broccoili in Penne Alfredo with chicken and broccoli.
Mmmmm... That reminds me of another "trick". Microwav meals. The microwaves break down the chemicals (proteins, etc.) in food in such a way that it's often possible that you can start off with a microwaved "new" food and "sneak" it onto the acceptable list... and then just start cooking healthier versions of the same meal in a few months.
But just for laughs (and because I haven't posted it in awhile)... here's another parent's "toddler menu" ;) I first came across it in my physiological psych class as we were going through the science behind why toddlers are picky eaters.
THE TODDLER DIET
People are always on the lookout for a new diet. The trouble with most diets is that you don't get enough to eat (the starvation diet), you don't get enough variation (the liquid diet) or you go broke (the all-meat diet). Consequently, people tend to cheat on their diets, or quit after 3 days.
Well, now there's the new Toddler Miracle Diet.
Over the years you may have noticed that most two year olds are trim. Now the formula to their success is available to all in this new diet. You may want to consult your doctor before embarking on this diet, otherwise, you may be seeing him afterwards. Good Luck !!!
DAY ONE
Breakfast: One scrambled egg, one piece of toast with grape jelly. Eat two bites of egg, using your fingers; dump the rest on the floor. Take one bite of toast, then smear the jelly over your face and cloth.
Lunch: Four crayons (any color), a handful of potato chips, and a glass of milk (three sips only, then spill the rest).
Dinner: A dry stick, two pennies and a nickel, four sips of flat Sprite.
Bedtime snack: Throw a piece of toast on the kitchen floor.
DAY TWO
Breakfast: Pick up stale toast from kitchen floor and eat it. Drink half bottle of vanilla extract or one vial of vegetable dye.
Lunch: Half tube of "Pulsating Pink" lipstick and a handful of Purina DogChow (any flavor). One ice cube, if desired.
Afternoon snack: Lick an all-day sucker until sticky, take outside, drop in dirt. Retrieve and continue slurping until it is clean again. Then bring inside and drop on rug.
Dinner: A rock or an uncooked bean, which should be thrust up your left nostril. Pour Grape Kool-Aid over mashed potatoes; eat with spoon.
DAY THREE
Breakfast: Two pancakes with plenty of syrup, eat one with fingers, rub in hair. Glass of milk; drink half, stuff other pancake in glass. After breakfast, pick up yesterday's sucker from rug, lick off fuzz, put it on the cushion of best chair.
Lunch: Three matches, peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Spit several bites onto the floor. Pour glass of milk on table and slurp up.
Dinner: Dish of ice cream, handful of potato chips, some red punch. Try to laugh some punch through your nose, if possible.
FINAL DAY
Breakfast: A quarter tube of toothpaste (any flavor), bit of soap, an olive. Pour a glass of milk over bowl of cornflakes, add half a cup of sugar. Once cereal is soggy, drink milk and feed cereal to dog.
Lunch: Eat bread crumbs off kitchen floor and dining room carpet. Find that sucker and finish eating it.
Dinner: Drop pieces of spaghetti onto back of dog, insert meatball into ear. Dump pudding into Kool-Aid and suck up with a straw.
REPEAT DAYS AS NEEDED!