Consumer Reports rated Neutrogena w/ helioplex as #1 one year, and the next year Up & Up (Target's brand). I buy Target's when I am near one since we don't have one here, it Neuteogena other times...they both seem to work great, and I've never had a problem. I also use "Ocean Potion face" SPF 45 for out faces, and sometimes bodies too. It is clear zinc...I read about it years ago in Glamour magazine as I have been battling brown spots on my face for over 20 years now....peels @ the estetician, every sunblock under the sun, reapplied hourly, expensive prescription sunblock, retin-a, hydraquinone, custom blended foundations...it didn't matter what I used.....5 minutes outside and they would reappear as dark as ever. I tried the Ocean Potion and it works great! It is less than $2 for a little tub, and a little goes a long way. My bestie who is Cambodian uses it on her whole body, she has sensitive skin and is afraid of getting dark as she said that in her culture it is very undesirable and her mother would have a fit! Good luck !