I loved stuffed animals when I was younger, but with 4 kids, they are definitely a pet peeve of mine. How many do kids really need? Get rid of them if you can, and like someone else suggested, donate them to a shelter or hospital or whatever. I'd keep one or two SMALL ones per child to sleep with and that's it. Believe me, if they decide to like them more at some point, somebody will buy them one or they'll ask for one when you're at a garage sale or store. My in-laws tended to buy some really large and ugly stuffed dolls & animals for my girls a lot when they were a little younger. I started a rule that if you bring a new one in, an old one goes out, otherwise their beds would be covered. I have made a point to mention this rule in front of my MIL so maybe she'd get the hint. That didn't really work, but since my girls are a little older now, they don't really buy them stuffed animals anymore. Actually, the littlest pet shop animals are great for about your daughter's age & up, since they are LITTLE. They aren't stuffed and you can fit 20 in a small purse. My boys have a few stuffed animals they sleep with, but that's all they do with them. Why don't you get some plastic farm animals or dinosaurs if you don't have some already as a replacement? Those things always see more action than stuffed toys.