Dear E. and all other interested Moms,
I know that a lot of what is listed below is going to rave rave rave about Britax being the best. I wanted to offer you another way of thinking about car seats. First, there is the safety issue.
Second, why not consider how toxic a carseat is, and whether it might be affecting your child's health? There have been a lot of articles linked to research that suggest the flame retardants found in many household items (including car seats!) could be absorbed by our precious babies' skin and potentially manifest through some serious long term health problems.
The website
http://www.healthycar.org
offers opportunities to search by type of seat, model and gives you best/worst in class breakdown options too.
www.safbaby.com notes from this:
"The very best choices for car seats/boosters (when it comes to lowest toxic concern) are:
* infant: Graco SnugRide Emerson and Evenflo Discovery Infant Churchill
* convertible: Cosco Scenara 5-point and Eddie Bauer 3 in 1 Convertible Montecito
* boosters: Evenflo Big Kid No-back Gold Dust and Britax Parkway Express
A note to the consumer: Just because one model of a specific brand is rated as the least toxic, does NOT mean that every model of this specific brand is rated the same way."
I have a large baby and invested in the Eddie Bauer Montecito when we had to upgrade to front facing. So far, although it doesn't seem to have a lot of padding and stuff, it does the job and keeps him snug.