Jennifer,
After reviewing the responses to your questions, I've been sitting here debating whether or not to respond. At the moment I'm pretty steamed at the lack of acceptance and understanding and the one-sidedness of the other posters here. So, I'm going to give you my thoughts, which are obviously not the most popular, but I fell are necessary to give you some balance.
My son is 11, he was diagnosed at 4 1/2. We tried all the food changes, behavior therapy, different ideas, etc. Noting worked. My kids don't eat processed food, or red dye, or anything else that "someone" suggested was the cause of the problem.
When, after much research and thought, we made the decision to start him on meds, our whole world changed. Up to the point of medication, he could not sit with a paper and crayon and color, he could not play blocks, he could not put simple puzzles together, he could not play with other kids, and a host of other issues. He was kicked out of one preschool within the first few weeks of school. We were blessed to find a developmental preschool that worked with his needs and strengths and watched a major transformation with him. Within six weeks of the first round of meds, I watched him write his name on a piece of paper for the first time ever. Now, some will blame his inability to do these things on my poor parenting skills, my laziness and many other things. Far from the truth. I ran a preschool/daycare in my home, I had a mile long waiting list for a spot in my program. My lack of skills, lazy behavior and all those other issues did not exist.
While some will tell you that meds are the lazy parents' way out, please know that is not the case all the time. Would you deny a diabetic child his insulin, just because someone told you to change his diet or that meds were the lazy mans solution? I'm not saying that the diet vs. meds issue is completely wrong. You do have to feed your children healthy food, giving them the best you can. Yes, some foods affect our children and if we can minimize those effects, good things are bound to happen.
A parent of an ADHD child cannot assume that just by giving their child meds, it will change all the behaviors and life will be easy from that point on. Our life has been difficult in many ways as we learn each new stage of our son's life and how to help him succeed. Meds are not the cure-all here, they are a step to help the children be successful. The meds do no cure the ADHD, they give the kids the ability to stop and think before making choices and a host of other things.
Our son is growing and we see maturity factor in to his decisions. But, without those meds on board, he does not have the same abiltiy to made decisions the same way. There are so many things being pumped into his brain, that his system is on overload. This is a huge issue for ADHD kids. You cannot remove all outside stimuli from your child's world. You can control how much and when they are exposed to excess noise, commotion, large groups of people, etc. Every child is different and it takes trial and error to figure out what will help them most.
Not all ADHD meds are in the stimulant family. Our son takes a non-stimulant med and has for the last several years. It does not work quite as well as the stimulants, but it serves it's purpose and it does not fill him full of outside stimulants. He does not drink coffee or Mt. Dew or any other "OTC" stimulant for self medication. If I thought a Mt. Dew every two hours would solve the problems, I still wouldn't do it. The sugar alone would rot all the teeth out of his mouth and cause a host of other health issues. Those things are not good for you, period.
You are a good person to want to do what you can for your family. It can be a tough decision, but do not sell yourself short of options because there are plenty of options out there. Do not let one thought process sway you from looking at all your options, one thing does not work for everyone.
From the parent of an ADHD child, thank you for caring.