H.B.
We switched to an HSA almost a year ago, and I love it so far! You should only switch over if you don't have any major medical problems etc. The deductible is high, but it is usually just used in emergency situations and unexpected things. In our HSA, all "well visits" are completely covered without using our deductible so it works with the kids really well. So you can maintain your family's health without putting out 1200 a month like you said. We get all of our prescriptions from Wal-Mart for $4 so it doesn't take much out of the deductible. We actually have an emergency fund set up, so that if something did come along (heaven forbid) we can easily spend the 2000 dollars without it even hurting us at all. If/when you switch over, set aside some money (the money you would have spent per month anyway) into some sort of savings account with a high interest, so you can make money while you save it for health emergencies. I hope this made sense to you, there is a lot that goes into the discussion. Anyway, it works well for our family. We save a lot of money by doing it this way. Good luck, and God bless.