i always have them for everyone. the littles dont know the difference, but i think its good that thier older sibs etc see that they count too, and some parents might even be offended. really, its just nice. if you go to target or wherever, they have those 3 packs of those fat crayons for babies, the ones with little animals shaped like a ball or something, i gave one of those to each baby one year, i gave cute little bibs another year, once i gave those balls with the sparkles inside, they had them in 4 packs in the favor aisle at target, smaller ones, like 2 inches across. one year i gave little stacking cup kits from ikea, once little rattly bracelets. a friend of mine gave a pack of those gerber graduates snack things to each baby one year, it was perfect. just a side note, maybe im a party pooper but i cannot stand when my kids are handed a bag of candy as we walk out the door of someplace amid the leaving a party chaos that i then have to take away or at the very least inspect before we get into the car because they are filled with little choking hazards and allergy peanut things etc and i have smaller kids. i hate having to be the bad guy. i love getting a gift that i can see is safe, or getting it a little earlier so i have a minute. we always do a pinata, which i hate, because my kids beg me, so we do it early, give each kid a ziplock to put their loot in, write their name on it with a sharpie, and give it to mom to hold or stash. your scavenger hunt would work perfectly like that. anyway--- happy partying! i love the scavenger hunt idea, i think im gonna use it this summer, perfect!