L.N.
Congrats on making it through the 1st year!! haha We had an Elmo party for my son's 1st also. He had a great time. We hired an Elmo character and he brought a sing along with hokey pokey, etc... Some kids loved it , some kids were scared. My son loved it! We also had an area set up for the kids inside, (in case it rained) that had a small ball pit, lil tike slide, and a variety of toys set out for the kids to play. We also downloaded coloring pages of Elmo and friends and in their gift bags everyone was given an 8 pk of crayons. Overall, organized games at that age will probably not work out, they just can't focus for too long and forget following any rules...it won't hapen. A few things set out and they will entertain themselves. Have fun!