My Baby Prefers My Mother in Law. Normal ?

Updated on April 09, 2018
B.L. asks from Arvada, CO
7 answers

Hi,
Here’s the story. I’m a first time mom. My baby is 7 months old. I’m a stay at home mom so I’m usually with my baby girl all the time except for when I go to school twice a week and occasionally go to the gym for 2 hrs at the most. This all started when my husband was in the icu for four days. I wanted to be constantly by his side in case anything happened. So I was in the hospital each day from the morning to the night (didn’t stay the night though.) Since I didn’t want my baby to be exposed to anything in the icu or be in the hospital in general, she stayed at home all day with my mother in law (MIL). Once hubby and I we’re home (we live with my in laws ) and everything was back to normal I started noticing that my baby would cry every time my MIL would walk by. I didn’t think anything of it but now my babygirl is always reaching her little arms out to my MIL and when I try and take her she turns away and rejects me because she doesn’t want to leave her grandma. I laugh it off in front of my MIL and hubby but inside I can’t help but feel jealous and hurt. I might be overreacting but it breaks my heart. It’s been a whole week and she still prefers her grandma over anyone. What’s going on ? Does she think that’s her new mom ? Does she think I’m boring ? Does she love her more than me now ? Idk I just feel so hurt it brings me to tears sometimes and I miss her always wanting to be with me. is this normal? And I wrong for feeling this way? Any advice on how to cope ?

Side note : For the record MIL has always been very stingy with my little one and I can tell she gets satisfaction out of the fact that my baby reaches for her when she’s with me. Then she’ll give me a smug look. Just a side note but this is really annoying me.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

D.B.

answers from Boston on

All kids go through phases, preferring Mom over Dad, Dad over Mom, Grandma over Mom, and so on. Being able to roll with the punches is really a critical skill in parenting. Look at it this way - you'll be so incredibly prepared for adolescence, when kids want nothing to do with their parents!

You did the right thing, taking care of your husband in the ICU. It's great that you had in-laws to help and be there during the day. I know how hard it is to be needed in the hospital but also needed at home. You chose wisely - you went for the one in crisis (your husband) and let your baby connect with others.

Long term, children are strengthened by knowing there are others who can and will take care of them. They need to be cared for, fed and put to bed by Mom, Dad, grandparents, aunts/uncles, and babysitters. Knowing they are surrounded by love makes them more secure.

Kids also bond, at least short term, with the one who is caring for them. Some kids dont' transition well at certain ages. That doesn't mean they don't love you, and at 7 months (or 17 or 27 months) they certainly don't think you're boring!

Now, whether your MIL is milking this situation to tick you off, I don't know. I do think laughing it off is a good strategy, especially since you live there. The more confidence you display, now and in the future, the better it is for your daughter, and the more it disarms your MIL. Don't let anyone see that it bothers you, and better yet, don' let it bother you!

This will change, I promise you. And a child's closest relationship will always be with her parens, especially the parent of the same sex. You have 17.5 more years of this. Bide your time and try to feel more secure about this.

6 moms found this helpful

B.C.

answers from Norfolk on

Kids develop favorites all the time.
They switch between mom and dad and grandparents - and sooner or later they switch back again.
Don't read anything into it and don't get all hurt and annoyed by it.
Like everything else - this will pass and eventually you will hardly remember it.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.P.

answers from Pittsburgh on

Your baby bonded with her grandmother. That's not a problem.

Please take a step back and stop fretting over this. You are truly over reacting.

Your baby KNOWS you are her mommy. That isn't going to change.

If you don't like other people bonding with your child? You might need to live on your own.
please stop letting this stress you out. That WILL make your daughter turn to others because she will FEEL the stress.. LET IT GO!

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.K.

answers from New York on

It’s wonderful for them to have a close bond. Be thankful.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.D.

answers from Pittsburgh on

It is a totally normal phase and it will pass. Keep laughing it off. Your baby knows that you are her mommy, and that is a bond that is unbreakable.

2 moms found this helpful

C.T.

answers from Santa Fe on

She bonded to your MIL while you were gone. This is a gift. Your baby was happy while you had important things to do. I would not take it personally...a good bond with another family member is a great thing for a child growing up. What I have learned with my kids is that they are ALWAYS changing. Both kids went through a mommy preference and a daddy preference. One of them went through a short time where they preferred one grandma over the other. It all changed. Your baby will get older and things will change. Spend as much time as you can being her main caretaker.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.G.

answers from Portland on

I think her reaching for grandma and feeling attached at this point is probably fairly typical where she was with her for an extended amount of time while your husband was in the ICU. Where you live in the same house, etc. she sees a lot of her.

My mom was heavily involved with one of my sister's kids for a similar reason, and they have a very strong bond - which is actually lovely. I would support it. It's great for children to have that as they grow up (a positive thing).

It doesn't replace what you have - at all. It may feel like it at this point in time, because babies seem so needy and it's like MIL is meeting her needs for now - but it's just a phase. Give it a week or two, and she'll be back to reaching for you I'm sure as well. It's not permanent at all.

I had my mom help out when I had babies - she would come and look after the others and it was always this way. I kind of cherished it because they didn't get to see her that often.

As for the smug look, etc. Not sure what that's about. That seems to be a different issue, and hard to comment on that. I wouldn't confuse the two though. I don't think a grandma can make a baby want her more - if that's what you are worried about if that helps.

2 moms found this helpful
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions