When I did this project I did't use a site, I just did it myself, using my computer. It's pretty easy to do. Here's what I did.
I divided the recipe's into different sections, like appetizers, salads, soups, salads, main dishes, side dish,cookies, cake, other deserts, candies, etc. You ca make what ever sections or divisions you want, depending on the types of recipes you have.
I then neatly typed up each recipe, adding any notes I felt were needed, i.e. where the recipe can from (grandma, aunt susie, etc) and any changes you've make (less salt, more sugar, etc.) of if the recipe is only used at the holidays or at family reunions.
I then get some plastic page protectors and put the printed recipes in those. I then find a pretty notebook of some kind, mark it somehow as a cookbook of special recipes, and voila you are done! You can even get dividers of some kind to put in to mark your different sections. There are many ways to go on this and you ca make it look as fancy or plane as you want without the use of a website, and often times much cheaper.