S.P.
Hi S.,
My daughter will be 12 on April 30th, so your question caught my eye. This is such a tough age to please! I understand what you mean about friends she should and shouldn't invite! I think the less friends, the better!! A movie and dinner sounds great!!! I'm sure she will want to feel like she is alone with her friends so maybe you can see a different movie at the same time. And eat at a different table (out of her sight!!)
I'm not sure what my daughter will propose this year; hopefully it will be something we can both agree on!!! Let me know what you and your daughter decide!!!