I don't have either of those, but I have been reviewing strollers for a little while for our 5 year old (30 lbs. and 40 inches tall) for Disney World trips. I just bought the MacLaren Volo stroller and it is perfect for this age. It is very lightweight, easy to fold, very roomy for a larger kid, has a carrying handle, and has a basket. I bought it the other day at BRU for $50 as they are clearancing their 2007 models right now. So, I love the stroller and so does my son. So, I considered the two you were looking at, and asked around and so many people recommended this seat above the 2 you mentioned so I just got this one. It should last for many more years to come. Good luck!