It depends on what you're wanting in a care provider. Just like you and your friends have different tastes in men, clothing, and hairstyles, so you and your friends may have different ideas of who the "best" OB/midwife is. Friends' recommendations may be good, but only if you're wanting the same thing your friends liked.
Go to http://www.TheBirthSurvey.com to see what reviews are available in your area for doctors, midwives, and hospitals. They are *not* all equal. It has been shown that the primary factor in whether or not a woman ends up with a C-section or other intervention is NOT due to some standard medical/scientific issue, but PRIMARILY due to her care provider's practice style. In other words, if your doctor has a 50-70% C-section rate, your odds are high of getting a C-section whether you need it or not. If your midwife has a 20% or less C-section rate (they don't actually *perform* the operation, but it is counted as "theirs" if one of their clients ends up having a C/s), then the odds are high that you will have a vaginal birth, and that if you end up with a C-section, that it was actually necessary/beneficial.
If you're the type of woman/patient who just wants to lay back and do whatever your doctor says, and your idea of a birth plan is "go to hospital; have baby," then you'll be happier with one type of doctor. If, however, you want to understand what is going on, and actually have some input into your own pregnancy and birth, and be able to make choices about yourself and your baby, then you'll be happier with a different type of doctor, and preferably a midwife. If you tend towards "natural" birth, you may want to get recommendations from other "natural"-minded people like at a La Leche League meeting, or from an independent childbirth educator in your area. ("Independent" just means not affiliated with a hospital.)
I would strongly urge you to see if there are any midwives in your area, because midwives are proven to be better for pregnancy and birth than doctors are (fewer prenatal losses, lower interventions during labor and at birth, and better maternal and neonatal outcomes). Obstetricians are surgeons, so they tend to use their surgical skills more often than truly necessary. They also tend to practice defensive medicine, which also drives up rates of intervention.
Your choice of care provider will influence your choice of birth place; and your choice of birth place will influence your choice of care provider. If you like the idea of a midwife, but the only ones available to you attend only home births, then you will have to have a home birth in order to have a midwife. Some midwives attend hospital births. In my area, we don't have any hospital-based midwives, and very few midwives at all! Some doctors and midwives attend births at only one hospital; some attend births at several hospitals.
All hospitals are not created equal, either. And don't be fooled by "spa-like surroundings" as a measure of whether you want to give birth at that hospital or not! Some hospitals advertise labor tubs, but have so many restrictions in place that no woman actually ever "qualifies" for getting into the tub. Ask about their rates for various interventions, including C-sections, episiotomies, vacuum and forceps extractions, epidurals, inductions and augmentations. This goes for hospitals and care providers alike, because both influence the likelihood of you ending up with some intervention. Ask if your doctor and/or hospital require continuous electronic fetal monitoring, as well as IVs.
Check out "The Thinking Woman's Guide to a Better Birth" by Henci Goer for more information.