R.T.
Rebecca M doesn't know what she is talking about and obviously has not seen the results first hand!! I have a 12 and a 10 year old and did the classes with them when they were toddlers, and now my 3.5 year old is on his second refresher course (he did the initial ISR course 2 years ago, then last year he did the refresher, and now he's doing the refresher again.) I obviously think it's awesome and have seen great results to have my 3rd child do it and to have him continue to do the refreshers, because it's NOT cheap! After teaching the child to float (as well as turn over and swim toward the edge of the pool), yes, they put the child in fully clothed. Thank goodness they do that! The idea is because often a child will fall in a pool or other body of water when they DON'T have their bathing suit on, and this is training their brain to understand that you can do this floating no matter what you are wearing (even shoes) AND no matter how heavy the clothes gets when it's wet. I have a photo in my cell phone of my son in jeans and a sweatshirt and sneakers, floating in the water! Now that he is 3.5, his instructor is having him do his lessons while holding or swimming toward a toy because it is realistic that a child will have a toy in his hand while playing at the pool's steps or possibly have something in his hand when he falls in. This is the best money I have spent!!! Find an ISR instructor (Safe Start at the YMCA is the same program, though I have liked private instructors better than the Y myself) and go and observe and make the decision for yourself. You do have to be committed to 10 minutes a day for SEVERAL weeks, and you do have to be strong enough to let your child cry (or actually SCREAM), knowing in your heart that you would rather hear screaming for 10 minutes a day than never hear your child's voice again because he drowned.