I've got a Whirlpool, the biggest Lowes had. We did NOT get the water thing on the outside because....I'm not sure about that. How clean is the water, is it just basically cold tap water, how would I clean the tubes or whatever over the years, etc...gross. We just drink our filtered water. There is NOTHING negative that I can say about our french doors, freezer on bottom! I had no preference of what fridge I got, and thought a freezer on bottom would be strange, but my husband is tall and said it makes sense to have the things you use everyday closer to eye level and the freezer (stuff you don't use as often) down lower. I was just like "whatever, get what you want" but WOW I love it so much! It's huge, spacious, works well, easy to organize and see everything at a glace, and quiet. The freezer does have an icemaker, the drawer works just fine and we do use it a couple times every day. I keep it very organized, not stuff thrown around, so it's not difficult to go through at all (and to me, at 5'2", it would be more of a pain to try to see whats at the back of the top shelf if the freezer was on top). Keep it organized and it's not different than any other freezer, except it's on bottom. It does actually seem BIGGER than the freezers that are on top (and SOOOOOOOO much better than the ones on side). Can't recommend it enough.