Hi S.. My husband and I struggled with infertility for 3 yrs before doing IVF and getting pregnant with our now 4-month old beautiful, healthy boy. We did not use either of the doctors you mentioned and I don't have info about them but, I wanted to let you know that we used Dr. Michael Putman of Baylor Dallas and I think he is a miracle worker! He is an exceedingly bright man and has the best experience in the metroplex. He has been on the 'Best of D' magazine for several years as one of the top endocronologists in Dallas. He was president of the North American Board of Infertility a few years ago and has 4 patents on surgical tools for infertilty (one of which he used on me!).
Most importantly to me though, is that Putman and his office are extremely kind, considerate and compassionate which is a must when you are going through infertility. And, his office is not money driven--in fact, Putman couldn't even tell us how much different procedures were because he said he didn't know about the money, we'd have to talk to his office. He is in it because he has a passion for helping people have children not because he is money hungry. That is a very different philosopy from some of the doctors in the metroplex.
I loved Putman and cried when we had to quit going to his office and go back to the regular obgyn. We'll be back next year to try for another little one.
One last thing, I read the posts that say that IVF is really hard on your body and they would never do it again, but that was not my experience. I didn't think the process was bad at all and in fact, my husband and I made the nightly shots almost fun because he liked being a part of the process and was a pretty good shot with the needles! I guess to me, the alternative of never being a mom, made the shots, hormones and other side effects just not seem like that big of a deal. I think part of that is that Putman is really good with the right doses of hormones without overloading you. I just had a very positive experience and will definitely do it again. It's a lot of money, but we'd blow it somewhere else and I'd much rather have a child than say, a new boat!
Best of luck to you and your husband. I certainly understand the struggles and wish you all the best. Being a mom has been more joy than I ever expected and every day,I thank God and Dr. Putman for my precious son. Good luck!