C.B.
Hi D.,
I am 48 and for years I use Avon wash-off waterproof mascara and need to remove it with Ponds Cold cream at night to get it to budge. I buy them for about $2 each when they go on sale once a year and then I buy 10 of them (normal price is $6.50). I wipe the brush each morning on a tissue before applying to get no clumps, and replace the tube once a month. Right now they have some mini ones on sale at Avon.com for 99 cents, so it would be easy to try. The part number for black is 583-377, Black/Brown 583-400,
Navy 583-415, Violet 583-420. I get mine from a woman at work who sells Avon.