Hi A., I just read your story, it touched me & I hoped your little girl passed into 6th grade, did she? I wanted to share my (similiar) story & SUGGESTIONS (below).
My neice, ALSO 11, struggled the SAME way. It was very sad to watch! (Although her Dad-- my brother-- had died in front of her a yr prior & a few months later.. her Mom left her & her 8 yr old sister who are now living w/their Aunt (my 52 yr old sister).
The school (Saddle Brook)was said to be a "great school system". I attended several meetings w/my sister.. meeting w/the principle, teachers, state worker, etc. to discuss her grades.. watched as they brain-stormed; offered after school help & told my sister what 'at home' role she SHOULD play; checking homework, encourage reading, etc.
I was happy w/the outcome & thought we were in the clear, until abruptly & at the LAST marking period my sister says: "she's failing". I asked WHY & found my sister had STOPPED checking her homework; told me "Well I wanted to see what she was gonna do, she has to learn to remember on her own, the teachers are tired of her daydreaming & dont' want to help her anymore if she's not helping herself"! She just turned 11 & all she'd been thru, I was outraged! Actually, my sister & I are barely speaking now over this.
FIRST I took my neices homework pad & wrote the entire MONTHS dates & the words: "Homework Assignment" at the top of each page to help her remember to write her homework assignments down everyday. I offered to pay for Sylvan Learn Center OR to visit her daily in after care to help her study (instead of playing)BUT my sister told me she didn't want my neice to "get all that attention" & that the ONLY choices at this point were to either have a therapist label her ADD -OR- JUST let her repeat the grade. Meanwhile I'm wondering what ever happened to "summer school" help. "JUST"? my sister says? A year of this childs life.. JUST sit back & watch her fail? When I knew this poor childs forgetting her homework .. doodling & daydreaming in class.. failing.. stemmed from "post traumatic stress". My sister would say (in front of her!) "she can read maybe 3 sentences & that's it her brain can't hold the info". NOT long after.. BOTH girls sadly, would tell me (mimic)the same thing: "OH Auntie we can't hold onto info we can only read 3 sentences". Again I was outraged instead of ENcouraging she was DIScouraging. The bottom line: my sister said the school was pushing ADD bcause it IS easier; that there were more State resources available. BUT I refused to accept that; I pursured it & found out there WERE other resources! Much like your daughter, she only had one marking period left tho. Thank God (& the teachers!) my neice passed the grade w/the help of after school assistance and NO ADD label!! I pushed my sister; my sister pushed the school .. the school pushed my necie & she passed !! You have to push.. they won't.
WANT TO ASK: Are you trying anything at home to help her read? Unfortuantley many young Moms (my family too) feel its simply up to the "school system" to teach; don't realize the sucess of the child relies on what goes on at home too. The combination of parents working WITH the teachers usually result in success stories.
ONE SUGGESTION: I bought alot of books for my neices & made it fun. I recently bought Madonnas "The English Roses" because it deals w/the Orphan topic (the girls can relate) & I read the book myself-- THEN-- I made up a fun test & gave them prizes... they were actually EXCITED to take a test! Without the pressure of teachers or the grade counting... it got them to READ. Much like I've heard parents struggling w/children not wanting to eat their vegetables, & heard you should give multiple choice offers: "do you want spinach, peas or corn" it gives the child the feeling THEY are making a decision, not being forced to "eat his/her veggies" while accomplishing them doing just that! So we'd say: do you want to read 'this or that' book! Either way .. they're reading!
Sadly-- my sister continues on; not encouraging reading this summer -- even tho the school absoultey emphasized the necessity! My sis claims she wants them to "have fun"! said: "come on they're kids what should they constantly study?".. Meanwhile they're not studying or reading AT ALL! Why? It's 'easier' .. easier to allow them to QUIETLY sit & play video games for 4-hours .. then to have to spend her time to PUSH them to READ or making up FUN games to help them WANT to read. Failing to realize she's ONLY putting off the inevitable.. September will SOON be here & the struggle WILL continue.. at this rate .. what will my sister do, have her quit school at age 16? I want to push college!
WithOUT at home help? Most children are bound to continue to fail. I told my sister we CAN'T just feed, clothe & put a roof over a childs head & call that: "great parenting". Actually -- the basic law-required aspects of raising a child are: "clothe, feed, schooling".
Technically I guess we don't have to do anymore then that & the school sadly is not going to push if the child lacks 'at home' assistance. There are just too many children in the school system they can't give one-on-one attention.. especially if the parents aren't doing much to help at home.
Parenting is a huge job & responsibilty.. its more then IF they eat but WHAT they eat.. (too much Burger King for my neices & not enough veggies & home cooked meals). Constant guidance & teaching VALUES.. READING .. etc. is what makes the 'good' parent stand out & proudly display the bumper sticker "Proud Parent of Honor Roll Student"; if thats what the parent wants that is.
Well I truly wish you the best of luck.. hope she graduated. My neice seemed as if she 'didn't care' but when she passed it was clearly evident how happy & relieved she was! Hope this helps.