B.,
I am new here and a SAHM of two, boy 7 1/2 and girl just turned 5. They are the light of my life! My daughter was plagued with ear infections for the first year and a half of her life, and my son didn't have ear issues at all. We, too, agonized over whether to get tubes for her or not (I myself had to had tubes when I was 3). We thought she was speech delayed or had a hearing problem because she didn't respond unless you spoke to her relatively loudly. Our ENT told us it was like she had been trying to hear while under water for the first year and half of her life (she had fluid behind her ears that much!)
Ultimately, we decided to do it. I can't tell you how glad I am. She was 16 months for the first set, and has had two sets since (at 2 1/2 and 4). She is a different child. Fortunately she has always been a good sleeper (even with ear infections) she never complained that they hurt (she'd always get a secondary infection in her sinuses or chest and we would discover the ear infections upon exams for those).
We discovered after all sorts of other tests (because she still continued to get the sinus infections) she needed to have her tonsils and adnoids removed, and finally, in December 06 after exhuasting every other possible treatment option, she had sinus surgery (for which she was very young to have but desperately needed). So, we were lucky and did "two for"s on the tonsils and adnoids and the the sinuses, because each time the previous set of tubes had fallen out and they were able to replace them at the same time as the other surgery. She was always able to swim, bathe, etc. normally with them. They gave her a huge reprieve from constant antibiotics (her infections would never clear up without them).
I know from what I write it sounds like we are surgery happy parents - - please believe that is not the case. The surgeries were always our last resort..after exhausting all other options. I am happy to report, she is doing well, with minimal infections and only anitbiotics twice since her sinus surgery. Her tubes have fallen out again, but our ENT doesn't think they are necessary unless she recurs with much greater frequency.
I honestly think she didn't know how good clear ears felt until after the tubes...she is a ray of sunshine.
I am not a fan of medicine unless absolutely necessary, but my perspective has certainly changed over the past three and a half years...because medicine is saving my son's life on a daily basis. He was diagnosed with cancer (Leukemia)at age four and has been in active chemotherapy since then. He is here with us today because we trusted our instincts as parents, and knew that we knew our child better than anyone else in the world. He finishes a 39 month chemo protocol next month, and God willing, he will be cancer-free for all his wonderful life to follow.
So, you see, my daughter was going through all this while he was in chemo, and, trust me, the last thing we wanted to do was be at the hospital again....we didn't jump to any surgeries. All I can say, is trust you instincts as a Mom, and believe that things will work out. GOOD LUCK!