Start with your realistic budget. What can you afford? What are the logistics (weather, size of your home/yard, etc)? Do you have a large, local family or will it be mostly your friends?
No judgement here on party size... we had 50 people for a huge BBQ with family flying in from around the country. It was a blast and 100% more for us than for him. Hey... you survived that first year!
Themes:
- Disney (Disney Babies is really cute)
- Fall (apples, pumpkins, soups, Thanksgiving, etc)
- Pick a color and go with it (pink, purple, etc)
We did a Mickey theme for our son's party, but didn't go crazy with it. The invites and cake plates were the Disney pattern. Everything else was solid colored (primary colors). We had burgers, hot dogs, different salads and sides and CAKE!
Keeping it simple? Immediate family and a few very close friends... order pizza and have a cake.
Have fun!