Couple of Potty Training Issues...

Updated on May 15, 2012
J.M. asks from Cleveland, TN
5 answers

My DD just turned 2 a couple of weeks ago. She is pretty much potty trained -she wears underwear during the day, stays dry through her naps, and only wears a diaper at night. I do put her in a pull-up if we are going somewhere that doesn't have immediate bathroom access or for a long drive, because at her age I don't expect her to be able to 'hold it' longer than the time it takes to let me know she needs to go. She has been doing great, without very few accidents for the last 3 months. We do have a couple of issues though...

1. How can I get her to TELL me she needs to potty? Her meathod is usually coming to me and whining... which she also does when she wants a snack, a drink, to read a book, etc. I have been really working with trying to get her to use her words, or to show me what she needs. I KNOW she can SAY the words... She just won't. I usually make her tell me what she wants before she gets it (if she comes whining to me for a drink, I will have her say drink before she actually gets it...) She won't take the initiative to say it on her own though. (I asked her pediatrician about her speech, and she is getting a speech evaluation done next week to see if she is behind on it... I know she comprehends everything I tell her, it's just her expressive speech that seems a bit behind...) Any advice how I can get her to use words before whining? Especially in concern to using the potty. The only time she ever has an accident is when I misunderstand what she is whining about. :(

2. She seems to dislike pooping in the potty. She won't take the initiative AT ALL there. She is fairly regular, so it's usually pretty easy for me to make sure she is on the potty when she needs to go... but unless I put her there ahead of time, she is content to go in her underpants. I know she knows when she needs to go, because she will usually go stand somewhere I can't see her to do it. She also has this "I'm gonna poop" face that she pulls a minute or two before she goes. (the trouble is that she usually pulls the face after she hides. :/) I have NEVER disciplined her for having an accident (my usual approach is to take her to the bathroom, clean her up, and have her sit on the potty while I rinse her undies.) so I don't understand where the hiding to go is coming from. Any thoughts?

p.s. She usues the normal toilet, not a potty seat. I usually help her up, she does her business and wipes herself (then I double check... lol.) and I help her down. We tried to use a potty seat for a while, but she hated it and greatly prefers the big toilet.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

R.R.

answers from Los Angeles on

As for the whining I have always told my guy I can't understand him when he whines, that he needs to use his words and I walk away or act disinterested if he continues to whine. Whining gets nothing from me, only clear words (to the best of his ability) gets him what he wants and that seems to prompt him to try to make himself understood. Once you have your daughter's speech evaluated you will know more and can then ask for advice in how to help her communicate best, even if she's just resisting telling you.

As for telling me he needed or needs to poop, he usually didn't or doesn't. He's been trained awhile, and I learned when i saw him go to hide or make a face to get him (now I tell him to go) to the toilet. Hiding is pretty normal, many children refuse to use the potty with another person in the room or nearby vicinity, they know they're doing something private and don't want to share it with the world, being disciplined for an accident doesn't necessarily bring hiding on. So YOU need to take notice for the time being, or keep rinsing her undies.

To make it easier for him to go independently we have always used a stool for him to climb up and down from the toilet. I think me expecting him to tell me (though he's very verbal) he had to go made him self-conscious so I put the responsibility of him getting to the toilet on him. Once he COULD do it on his own without involving me (except for clean-up assistance) he wasn't hiding anymore.

And, he was a poop holder, would hold it for days, so I went on the site:
http://www.rogerknapp.com/medical/pottytrainingrefusals.htm

which taught me about a "power incentive" ~ the incentive that works for YOUR child to use the potty/toilet. He was literally running to go poop on his own in just a little over a day after I introduced his power incentive, so check the site out for ideas that may help you to help your daughter.

2 moms found this helpful

V.W.

answers from Jacksonville on

Here are my suggestions, take what you like and leave the rest:

1) Teach her to sign the words for using the bathroom. If she has any verbal issues, signing will help alleviate the miscommunications AND the anxiety over trying to get the information out. And you won't have to hear whining. It's also discreet if you are out in public. :)

2) Get a step stool for the bathroom. You might still have to help her up, or maybe not. It might stimulate her desire to be independent a bit more, and get her to initiate going without coming to you in the first place. BUT, it also will give her some stability when she is pooping. It might help her to be able to put her feet on something solid when she is 'going'. It is something that we as adults take for granted.

3) Give her an incentive to poop in the potty as well. I don't think it is uncommon for toddlers to hide at poop time. But if she doesn't mind what comes after, she doesn't really have an incentive to change anything. I let my kiddos pick a fruit flavored lifesaver out of a clear ziploc bag after each successful potty trip. It was a BIG DEAL for them, b/c they got to be in control and make some choices. Grape or green apple or cherry or watermelon flavors??? hmmmmm... eventually, they get tired of choosing or caring about it, but the habit of going potty sticks with them forever. :)

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B.M.

answers from Los Angeles on

She's just barely 2. I wouldn't necessarily expect her to tell you when she needs to go. My son was over 3 and he still didn't tell me. At her age, you just need to keep taking her into the bathroom and saying "let's go potty." After a while, she'll get it and tell you or just go in by herself when she's capable. As for poop, that takes longer and you'll just have to keep putting her on the potty. If she's willing to go, you've made it through half the battle.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.W.

answers from Minneapolis on

There is usually a pretty long lag between the time they can be without diapers and the time they will consistently tell you they need to go. I would just tell her at regular times during the day that it is time to go and take her there (after meal and nap times, etc.) My daughter was in daycare and they had several regular bathroom times each day, so it was something she was used to.

Hiding to poop is also very common. My older SD had a table she would hide under, every time. I didn't use rewards for my younger daughter, but I wouldn't be opposed to using a small reward for pooping on the potty, to see if that encourages her. I agree with the stepstool idea, too. Do you use a toilet lid cover - the kind that fits on the lid and makes the hole smaller so they won't feel like they might fall in? We used one of those for awhile, until she got comfortable with holding herself up.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.L.

answers from Los Angeles on

You could teach her the sign for potty or a potty song if she responds to music.The hiding thing is just her age and there isn't anything you can really do about it. She is a bit young to be expected to be consistent. The average kid doesn't consistently go on their own with no prompting until more like 2 1/2. Don't be surprised if she has times of regression, especially if there is any stress or changes happening around her. Very normal for that age.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions