J.- I was wrestling with the same exact decision a little over 3 years ago. Though I have to admit, my reasons for not wanting Christiana were way less noble than yours (basically I was being caddy and didn’t want to be at the same hospital where my stepdaughter had been born six years earlier--- oh, the silly things you worry about before you have kids!). But I am SO HAPPY that my ridiculousness led me to CC hospital! It was amazing. Now I honestly can’t imagine having a baby at a big hospital. Chester County is really the best of both worlds--- it’s small and friendly while still having a top-level NICU. You didn’t mention which practice you had found, but if it’s Chester County OB/GYN Associates then I say FULL STEAM AHEAD! They were incredible and were a big part of the amazing experience I had at CC hospital. You didn’t mention where you live, but if you are closer to Newtown Square, you can go to most of your appointments there so that you aren’t schlepping to West Chester every week. I’m not sure why anyone would have something to complain about LD—I thought it was great. You labor and deliver in the same room, so once you get there, you don’t have to move until you have your baby in your arms. Those rooms are very spacious and private. My only only complaint was that it seemed like a long time for my epidural to come after I asked for it. But this was completely my fault because I was trying to be superwoman and make it as long as I could. Who was I kidding? Just make sure to order your drugs before you feel like you are going to pass out from the pain Please feel free to message me if you have any more questions about CC hospital or CC OB Associates. My husband and I are both really passionate about the amazing experience we had there.
PS--- I also 2nd what Lady said--- I liked having a CC doc check the baby out at the hospital and then going to our regular pedi at Brandywine Peeds the day after we got home. I liked having 2 different, unrelated pedis, both tell me that my baby was a-ok.
PPS--- I was in a maternity room that was built for 2, but never had a roomate. They let my husband stay in the room with me all 3 nights! it was great.